On Mon, 2019-01-28 at 10:19 +0530, Karthikeyan Periyasamy wrote:

> > At the same time, what happens today actually? Do all frames from non-
> > associated clients come up to the host? If so, is this not a problem 
> > for all APs, not just ath10k?
> 
> Today, without this patch. No frames from non-associated clients come up 
> to the host in AP mode.

So it's not just _filtering_ but also enabling to see them, right?

> > And if they don't come up, what feature requires this? Sorry for the
> > vague questions, but I'm not really sure what this is all about. If
> > there's a need for these frames, wouldn't we need a generic way of
> > enabling receiving them, and perhaps even signalling hostapd with them?
> 
> Steering application use this feature in their logical part of client 
> steering.

But there aren't even any steering applications that are open source or
anything like that, right?

I don't see why we should include this upstream. Clearly you can use
this for whatever you like to do with your driver in non-upstream
builds, and you can open-source this code, but if there are no
applications that could possibly use it upstream why bother?

johannes

Reply via email to