All, no objections have been received.
We will move forward and ask to put these two documents in HISTORIC state. Thanks Ciao L. > On 20 Nov 2019, at 03:43, Luigi Iannone <[email protected]> wrote: > > Folks, > > as discussed yesterday during the f2f meeting, we plan to move RFC7954 and > RFC7955 to HISTORIC state. > > Rationale is described in the text provide below. This text will be > associated to the documents so to keep track of the LISP EID prefix > experiment. > > Please let us know if you have any comment. > > We plan to move forward in one week time. > > Thanks > > Ciao > > L. > > > > > > —————————————— PROPOSED TEXT——————————————— > > RFC 7954 created an experimental IPv6 prefix, namely 2001:5::/32, to be used > as Endpoint-IDentifier (EID) space for the Locator/Identifier Separation > Protocol (LISP). The reserved address space was requested for an initial > 3-year period > starting in September 2016 (until September 2019), with an option to extend > it by three years (until September 2022) upon the decision of the IETF. > RFC 7955 describes a framework for the management of the prefix crested by > RFC 7954. As described in RFC 7955, RIPE NCC volunteered to provide > registration service during the experiment (up to 2022 at latest). > > The initial experiment was supposed to last three years, until September 2019. > The option to extend the experiment to three more years was subject to the > requirements written in section 10 of RFC 7954: > > Following the policies outlined in > [RFC5226], upon IETF Review, the decision should be made on whether > to have a permanent EID block assignment by September 2019. If no > explicit action is taken or, if the IETF Review outcome is that it is > not worth having a reserved prefix as a global EID space, the whole > /32 will be taken out from the "IANA IPv6 Special-Purpose Address > Registry" and put back in the free pool managed by IANA. > > In August 2019 RIPE NCC contacted the LISP WG asking if any action was > ongoing concerning the extension of the experiment. The LISP WG concluded > that very few requests have been made during three years and there was no > compelling reason to extent the experiment. No further action has been taken > by the LISP WG or the IETF. As such, in accordance with Section 10 of RFC > 7954, RIPE NCC de-registered the existing assignments and IANA put the prefix > back in the free pool (removing the entry from > https://www.iana.org/assignments/iana-ipv6-special-registry > <https://www.iana.org/assignments/iana-ipv6-special-registry>). > > At this point, RFC 7954 and RFC 7955 refer to a prefix that does not exists > anymore. As such it make sense to move both documents to the status of > "HISTORIC". This note, associated with the status change of the two RFCs will > allow to keep track of the LISP EID prefix experiment.
_______________________________________________ lisp mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/lisp
