On June 3, 2022 at 7:18:01 PM, Joel Halpern wrote:
Joel: Hi! > It is clear that this document is on the edge of the charter for the > LISP WG. It does not change LISP, but rather explains how to use LISP > to achieve a goal. Of course, if it were in some other WG it would > still need LISP review, so keeping it here makes snse. Particular since > it is not really about ipwave stuff. The part of the draft that describes the use of LISP is confusing and incomplete, but that can be fixed. However, there are other parts that are not about LISP. Those parts are the ones that I don't think belong to this WG: AAA extensions, H3 specifics, application layer packet formats, etc. I see that Sharon started looking at my review, so let's wait and see what shape the document takes. > The other important note is that way back when Sharon first brought this > work forward, I went to various AD, chairs, and influential participants > and tried to get a review on the geoloc / geopriv dimensions so that we > could properly consider them. I could one review, which brought up only > a few points (which Sharon then clarified in the draft.) It was very > clear that there was no interest from that community in looking closely > and engaging on this work. No interest by the community is not a positive indicator. :-( Thanks for the extra background. Alvaro. _______________________________________________ lisp mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/lisp
