Hi, Henry. Excellent work.

On Fri, 12 Sep 2003, Henry Baragar wrote:
><SIDE NOTE>
>"bincimap-subscribed" is a pain to edit by hand.  I know that this file 
>(...)
>RECOMMENDATION:  Define the format for ".bincimap-subscribed" (sic, and as 
>(...)
>Implications:
>1.  All non-mailbox files/directories must start with a "." (as discussed 
>in another thread); although removing junk files is not that painful when 
>each one is on its own line.
>2.  The folder separator needs to be converted from "/" back to "."

Nr 2 - I do not follow. Why do we need to change the folder seperator? :/

></SIDE NOTE>

A good side note. I actually agree. The subscribed file has a very simple
structure and should therefore be completely flat.

>Note that I had to exit Netscape each time in order for it to really 
>unsubscribe for the folders that I "Unsubscribed"; if I went to subscribe 
>again before exiting, Netscape displayed all the folders that were 
>unsubscribed as subscribed which would hold true for the next invocation 
>of Netscape.

Yes - I discovered this bug also recently. The LSUB, SUBSCRIBE and
UNSUBSCRIBE commands are today not stateless, while they should absolutely
be. So LSUB should always load the subscription file, and SUBSCRIBE and
UNSUBSCRIBE should always load, modify, then save.

>Overall, there are operational differences between Courier and bincIMAP, 
>and possibly between a Maildir++ and an IMAPdir depot.  I hope that I have 
>provided enough information for someone to unravel these mysteries.

Perfect! Thanks for this feedback - I'll dig into it and see what I can 
come up with. :-)

Andy

--
Andreas Aardal Hanssen    | http://www.andreas.hanssen.name/gpg
Author of Binc IMAP       | "It is better not to do something 
http://www.bincimap.org/  |       than to do it poorly."

Reply via email to