r1414 removed hotplug from the udev_update branch. Part of this seems to contradict what I said in my "Bugs in udev_update branch" mail to lfs-dev. Clarification follows.

1) There is no udev_retry bootscript on the CD, because nothing can be meaningfully retried. A retry is mesningful only if there is a possibility that the RUN="program" rule failed because of something not mounted. But everything is always mounted on the CD.

2) Linux-2.6.15 is used, because there is no pre-made reiser4 patch for 2.6.16-rc4. This does mean that the ide-tape module cannot be autoloaded, but this is not a regression against the regular LFS. Input subsystem bugs are worked around by compiling input drivers as non-modules.

3) The "cdrom" and "mouse" rules: yes, they are buggy.

Also, I attempted to make sure that kernel configs for all architectures expose the same features. Namely, all IDE and SCSI drivers are builtin, all ethernet drivers are built as modules, there is no sound, and all NLS support is full and modular. This was done by updating the x86 config, then concatenating the new x86 config with old arch-specific configs and running "make oldconfig". I am not sure that the result is good for all architectures, especially sparc. Please fix any breakage, it is not intentional.

Please don't distribute the ISO images without hotplug to the general public, as this would result in spamming the livecd list with uevent leak reports (such reports are, however, welcome from LFS developers).

--
Alexander E. Patrakov
--
http://linuxfromscratch.org/mailman/listinfo/livecd
FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/faq/
Unsubscribe: See the above information page

Reply via email to