On 06/29/16 18:45, Mike Holmes wrote:
This works but it should not improve the test suite coverage.

This is an example and only the test/validation suite counts towards code coverage metrics, It should be modified to be part of a test suite run test/validation.


packet mmap is linux-generic so test/ is not suitable for it. platfrom/l-g/test/ is better place. Probably I can create some script there to eat this pcap.


However in checking this patch I see that check-odp is actually including the example data in our code coverage, this is a bug. We want LCOV to reflect how well the validation suite exercises an ODP implementation code base since the validation suite is part of the sign off for compliance, the examples are not.

Mike

At least we need code covered. API functions have to be covered by validation tests. All internal things might not have such strict requirement.

Maxim.

On 23 June 2016 at 12:40, Maxim Uvarov <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

    Mike, do you want to add your Review for this patch?

    Maxim.

    On 06/20/16 14:12, Mike Holmes wrote:

        I like this, I believe we need to make passing more and
        greater varieties of packets thought the tests a much bigger
        part of the validation suite.

        Would it be better to start storing the pcap files in one
        place rather than making copies so that it is easier to
        maintain, we already duplicate one pcap file three times.

        mike@mike-laptop:~/git/odp$ find . -name *.pcap
        ./example/packet/udp64.pcap
        ./example/l2fwd_simple/udp64.pcap
        ./example/switch/udp64.pcap


        On 20 June 2016 at 12:04, Maxim Uvarov
        <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
        <mailto:[email protected]
        <mailto:[email protected]>>> wrote:

            Use vlan tagged traffic for example validation test
            to add code coverage for pkt_mmap_vlan_insert() internal
            function.

            Signed-off-by: Maxim Uvarov <[email protected]
        <mailto:[email protected]>
            <mailto:[email protected]
        <mailto:[email protected]>>>

            ---
             example/packet/Makefile.am  |   2 +-
             example/packet/pktio_run.sh |   2 +-
             example/packet/udp64.pcap   | Bin 7624 -> 0 bytes
             example/packet/vlan.pcap    | Bin 0 -> 9728 bytes
             4 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)
             delete mode 100644 example/packet/udp64.pcap
             create mode 100644 example/packet/vlan.pcap

            diff --git a/example/packet/Makefile.am
        b/example/packet/Makefile.am
            index af729b0..2d8ac5f 100644
            --- a/example/packet/Makefile.am
            +++ b/example/packet/Makefile.am
            @@ -14,4 +14,4 @@ if HAVE_PCAP
             TESTS = pktio_run.sh
             endif
             endif
            -EXTRA_DIST = pktio_run.sh udp64.pcap
            +EXTRA_DIST = pktio_run.sh vlan.pcap
            diff --git a/example/packet/pktio_run.sh
        b/example/packet/pktio_run.sh
            index 3adb2d6..0eb961a 100755
            --- a/example/packet/pktio_run.sh
            +++ b/example/packet/pktio_run.sh
            @@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
             # SPDX-License-Identifier:     BSD-3-Clause
             #

            -PCAP_IN=`find . ${TEST_DIR} $(dirname $0) -name
        udp64.pcap -print
            -quit`
            +PCAP_IN=`find . ${TEST_DIR} $(dirname $0) -name vlan.pcap
        -print
            -quit`
             PCAP_OUT="pcapout.pcap"
             PCAP_IN_SIZE=`stat -c %s ${PCAP_IN}`
             echo "using PCAP in=${PCAP_IN}:out=${PCAP_OUT} size
        %${PCAP_IN_SIZE}"
            diff --git a/example/packet/udp64.pcap
        b/example/packet/udp64.pcap
            deleted file mode 100644
            index
        
45f9d6e6341a331125e1e3e49ab8ad1e71b20712..0000000000000000000000000000000000000000
            GIT binary patch
            literal 0
            HcmV?d00001

            literal 7624
        zcmca|c+)~A1{MYw_+QV!zzF1AIDRVZQX4OW4Ui4OOdthJV3Lu8!IgnQ52VaNFl`SP
        zPy-M%&2gOL#31#rG%+bTB{eNQBQq;ICpRy@ps;AvtkLiqO%tPeXtbOdEel8Mj?wyY
        zv^_D}W*Ti5GK{vPNBat+eXG&_<7gilID#<RE*xzaj<yR&+l8a;!qKvDbPRcP%zboT
            XVRY^UIO8<hE*$M6kM@y?=pzFFfL+O&

            diff --git a/example/packet/vlan.pcap
        b/example/packet/vlan.pcap
            new file mode 100644
            index
        
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..106ccb682e51495b4025337518a0bce63c2c7681
            GIT binary patch
            literal 9728
        zcmeHNeQXrR6@R<F^Iq)3b|{=(C16{8IUt}71RM^-2~wIU*pOl>ikyh3QAN~9xK+}$
        z4T)^-QnlAgC4W>Yk*X>mRlo92km}Nw!c|oiNTn)LBLcyK0BKSYLZiA0xI}f|@6FEc
        z&CT8}Zu4i?dS2hYnK$pf`MuxF&iVB}9(>lN6zOYfipb#)S3BqRK6jeva#{)P%KZ4H
        z2`Z!uf1f`})Rm#nP<lLnYk>-l2Nx8d?iyv8ohr8v56pV)=ly+yzZvNmzS?$(tvQ({
        zN`3H(bKv=xSCLCcs6x0O=6jaXv{mjz%{=NyEc#gk|LwB0u=KHqz1)uIAM9Usn@mg_
        zk2Z3jR&?;MUcTp8vTSb+>k8B@8d$;SEO~No<@;@ZpT?k%M|X%lk9|?s`aqYWyx8+Z
        z0ekoid$_k!Cq3-<X$<;!oI~ik=uuzyOrT5ATGkaPBO2JlXV}BNmHltQH1XBQqGIxB
        zljw+U^mWzt`dC-+XBzhK8TN2Tj(!$l@3W%oreFHHd@xpu)``6eKOy$gmCxBdp4?km
        zcOk;wono&-@A$eG`7XZiNzwWmd-x3haEHC`0}y;QvZ#0!b{bfxaRTgY=FeI7XemDg
        zrt~v(2bR#*#*@ZM8*9~NW2GVr#A;%NVz9F1ZjF^e?ya$>uoBL#iIo(6N4XHj>S(MG
        zeb3ib&#l6WQUqAxJ_;+1G%sQ<6jmy<(AQPlQ&<V@nONzj-$&R}SgBCO*Ck?w=N1@3
        ztzC_<r?BGDHD4ECg)ywKqF4*@npnxu3)8|1QTKm^m5M(TBzz!q>u6q?Ejk-3sTiy%
        zJLqU*1*lbZW@5#)vBLROyi$q5N@&mI6<4qV_HQ01DswYP6#Khh&#x#j`~T|OCi|bb
        zN3;J^@0;w82*T>sY!!z<-^(tatsc~D<=O~jv?n9bxA(ZuR@_G+(2YT0#YW(iMxbxc
        zLZBOiz%;k6x2kCtQg)HA>t~@#46@u{#j=rA!7#$$CbB9q$Z}(l71}eARf%CCH-?2m
        zdtf0!=0&0c`wW?qD??ss=9y8V-J`2{2h$^47+;s#M(N!gA6oF=4y70DLnrRc7wjFF
        zOx)+JEMT8A&qVskA84dEJRcza81^~gx*CC0u1|&3bPQLjeGd2o2!%a`RQ9+oSCWm?
        zfGfKtTAM4q7^HeU`u~Dd8B&mS{p)1}QkhfLdKua?kxJ7;D%*=(FFD6*y`<?OmF>l^
        zmt?b5fB`qaKtG2kYe<9MTZQq~VxY+<h-x;~d#f3~&R#D=d**scG&arkGRI?>d#f#X
        zC-1F%$Jh;<)qLNa>FllkkCp7lgq7o*eqgVOD_&tEZf{L=#F~HiI`-D;-3T*n&wsd=
        zGr8jW-oxxwEwpEHg=cUD*#9!K|9#A<kf?o*vpIho*njMx$^K{hH2Xg}X0pFjF;}?S
        zg?TY+W$2}>m0g;Fych=ZV%Eygp6u8k*ZU<ehJierftb<2IMr{9CIfj?pMlb(8K@Rj
        z$o3L`#oxq<hN#m7mGe>mOo3LGZ$h?rzm4+*WW0SiRYs-<W}WF9Y1=#eX@6JA>+A&1
        z6<~FR<Af&_1)NcsR@39<n_=~fdE4sQ?IRtJ?fAxsnnT~}v0Trei#VBp-~zsz<$QwZ
        zhdl$C?4;5|r=G9K9Q(-%d8OMrIdwGG^Oqt{A0Ybbl^XN=lhQ-iCC@izetSZ-RQ+Es
        zq7ope$T_TPtm>cZIbrB=T4CznDB`pN0v}Lu>#O=_=?(F(i=TJYjDJ}CKUqZOK;XlW
        zW&ce>|FES$T?GCi@Bt?r&luyM7XKF29e=!tnt;HE4=wv=3_VUm%=ph1@rDb54>%Dq
        z$3H9n?W;TfTSe3m1U~Gy?4LLEI6X1Pzfi<34+0->f|57lzaakAAOGzlY7PP){$$yI
        z$I#=n#T@_LB6b82_<$3a7acH@#^1Z*-@Ll<|E&nzLEyuqyhAYUUo`YMoiX*7ia3dZ
        z;A-ItTIyoYpzG&S@h;ZoU6)S)@O)!t$5R`F`pHhJ{%EiI)z;Ss3HYC|@IPqeU+H0A
        z)kSUn{WAgI9~yd`*qHHOG4PL58xwz5#6O%M&W^0Vs|oo2m!ZcAk2(G|1OGVXF~`3q
        z{ykZD{Ergw{cl5$6Crc_DFgo%)|>dB694LtPo--7+xT`x5BA^1?EeJsNFY&biu+J`
        z4%q)ozcAT<=luh-6#JLUCj0BE!@HIlRYR$|s&F=CR#ig@)wZy1R#T<ws<Nx5(a_@@
        z%N##bs;#PSqpC6`RMm2>s%&Icss8L9pLwC`YO5++s$O;MRi&*|y(-wKpH-@6Z5x#x
        zrD|5SQFF5~>vsOT67sV!!T-ex{x3`L|JGRlfyPUW#!Z}ANYs9kR_0d$jlVvQ-3<__
        zzBM_!y}xhg{UdE(-nw?Pv7elP)eUZ<)zxD4m~D0Fz)0JJ9Z^=tXR=k^G(w^(C$+LX
        z7girQXI9S80aZDBhZpdHIlkcu_f4x3W^hfy3>Fe*@Q#ETyfa}2H^<Iku4ju>uwJ*p
        zTm8nmq4bzs#b>qa#@2-RKWFH%k2WiOo53*HOPdU{P5i^@`pn36V=y7VpEvY)^Eb!e
        zVKGe3V3-}kF!PyVnj;xT^+$eGzgmVFN|@hW3G@3v!u;+|nBRvI^1sK*|8Zmfl^*e_
        z=jQy+d~7(#FE;^v<b46{KXnc71z)xDd&J1E(xbh4UYozK1^L4&Wi#|Q6Y}>&LjLw8
        z<nLRt`2$xCe<G2qdWEZAvAJp&bJgDA`4a&H9tX3)>LcwAy~<gEMDpsP{Ow|OL!{M?
        zy~CGxnpQXQw}sm|hc~d`YNjsQ!0+vN*2Ln_T-HGxxocg<Z{H-n@T)WE2V0J`$8Y@1
        z4RoIL>tx#yoVIkz`Sa8B9XijSA(4^2mR}>0-BJ_Tss29B7e_YvoEaIu-^}r7-=$^F
        z6~cGXX+DRoz`pSeQC2_O!0pfvZ7;gZocCA|HJ+)q%N#r>S}s!E9?#x$mpi>Ywi-))
        zzlqPPulkI+{1I<Q$9P~!WW+Dz^Aho(8Sz_>=!jps-HaGs&hb6xvm83*LP+jfr{?Bf
        zI_W|jxoaKf2D63d>gQgWH`vr!f<1NJC-ZiBu|or#2S`*D&f5H1L^1ZenkfFNqp0wI
        zSNQ)QAvgyjv46|5;Cj<-r46np&s0uZI3frlYYB8{@6ZhP9)c)li1)B%M;7X4_~V3;
        zweY?r!UwhjTaiBax{uQbVC0ia6YITCFtX0f?z#7McFRAtvy0s`aDWT^itOSU<``9e
        z*o8Q9*E$t7pW+Ae-z3@9wtyG(Q9m~XI#usY+z*2OO@f;?E}jJRuan5`F(W(w6&+cA
        zwHX;uyoe*XMIvi=PPq_Zq+RM4y2TP<&N=BqfRS9F>k(Zw`a|6ku?bs}H2&4@V19<y
        zID}Ini24?e_AhE5T`)?NmT%$iQtg$F&ri|}c4@KSDc;0y{aiISvdwh*S?0(k1@)&>
        zQ7plIU*=6|dR#J=D<oFhda1NSH5ognGq!{Y*RQl!v7!LwU*O1E{OJDRV*$_b-zLDq
        zQO3ei&J^yz0(2S+l^`1m3)&VifIih&fKFqf!Wckb+_euHkKzNjM0<@#!v|j%=L2j_
            H$A|v_$relS

            literal 0
            HcmV?d00001

            --
            2.7.1.250.gff4ea60

            _______________________________________________
            lng-odp mailing list
        [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
        <mailto:[email protected]
        <mailto:[email protected]>>
        https://lists.linaro.org/mailman/listinfo/lng-odp




-- Mike Holmes
        Technical Manager - Linaro Networking Group
        Linaro.org <http://www.linaro.org/>***│ *Open source software
        for ARM SoCs
        "Work should be fun and collaborative, the rest follows"





--
Mike Holmes
Technical Manager - Linaro Networking Group
Linaro.org <http://www.linaro.org/>***│ *Open source software for ARM SoCs
"Work should be fun and collaborative, the rest follows"


_______________________________________________
lng-odp mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.linaro.org/mailman/listinfo/lng-odp

Reply via email to