Hi Bruno,

> As you know, there are several TLVs that have been MP-TLV for a very long 
> time (e.g. ROUTER CAPABILITY).  Having these be MP is a practical operational 
> necessity already today.  Disabling this on any node would likely break any 
> network that has some fairly common features (e.g. FlexAlgo) enabled.
>  
> [Bruno] I meant for the newly defined MP-TLV. The one for which MP handling 
> is changed by this document.  TLVs which have been defined with MP-TLV from 
> day one do not create interop issue. It’s the change of behavior when 
> handling TLV X of a new implementation which create an interop issue with the 
> handling of TLV X from old implementations.
> If it’s just a wording issue, I’m confident that someone can craft the right 
> wording.
>  
> What is the point of a knob that cannot be turned off?
> [Bruno] I agree that the point is to be able to turn it off.


Then you’re back to requiring per-TLV configuration. No thanks.

Also, I don’t think we’re trying to create any “newly defined MP-TLV”.  The 
point is to codify what has been done and create a default path moving forward.

T

_______________________________________________
Lsr mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to