>>> I guess he means it's a little cumbersome to do it your way. 
>>> Imagine a network of 500 machines or one where people with new 
>>> computers join and leave by the hour.
>> 
>> thats not what he wrote.
> 
> Actually he did. Basically your solution says that you define all
> known machines and deny all others by default while he wants
> something that is a mix of having some defined addresses, some
> random and a specific list of denied MAC addresses.

hmm ..

> However I think on the practical level he is better of blocking at
> the switch rather than in this way. it is pretty trivial to pick a
> random ip address if you know the range in use and the relevant
> gateway and this can cause even worse havoc. In any case, what are
> you trying to block them from accessing?
> 
> You could simply put those particular clients on a separate V-LAN.

agree, if the unwanted boxes are very many.

rgds
ernest
_______________________________________________
LUG mailing list
[email protected]
http://kym.net/mailman/listinfo/lug
%LUG is generously hosted by INFOCOM http://www.infocom.co.ug/

Reply via email to