|
Thank you Andreas and Ashley. Together your answers really helped. Though the file creation rates did only improve by 2x, all file listing operations are now about 20x as fast. The problem was that ACLs were not activated on the MDS but requested by default aliased "ls". Every single line of "ls -l" returned a "Operation not suported" error message with strace and took about 100-300ms. Thanks again! Robert Am 12.08.2010 18:22, schrieb Andreas Dilger: On 2010-08-12, at 10:10, robert wrote:I am trying to solve a problem with very slow "ls" and other big amount of file operations but good overall read/write rates.We are running a small cluster of 3 OSSs with 9 OSTs, 1MDS (with SSD MDT) and currently two clients. All server nodes are centos 5.2 with lustre 1.8.1 while the clients are centos 5.4 with lustre 1.8.3. All components are networked with DDR IB. Striping is set to 1 or 2 for different folders.I don't recall if there are specific metadata improvements in 1.8.3 vs. 1.8.1, but it is usually better to have newer RPMs than older. Note that if you have 1.8.1 (vs. 1.8.1.1) there is a corruption bug in the MDS, and you definitely need to upgrade.From the very beginning of our tests we had rather slow metadata operations. File creation maxed at 250/s/client.For DDR IB that is definitely slow."ls" of a dir with 1000 files takes about 40-70 seconds almost independently from the file´s sizes. Dirs that have recently been accessed, are of course much faster due to caching. There is no general performance problem as we are getting almost 1G/s when reading/writing big files from two clients in several threads. But when creating lots of files with lmdd in a test script in a single thread there are also hangs of a few seconds before the rates get back to normal. I´ve been searching the mailing list archives for similar problems but only found the usual "improving performance for small files" hints. All these suggestions have been tested but did not or only slightly improve performance. Can anyone please tell me ... - Is there a way to check the amount of time that the different parts of a file operation take (like 1ms requesting metadata, 1ms receiving metadata, 123ms reading blocks from OST, ...)?You can use "strace -ttt" on the client to see the time of each syscall. You can look at the various "stats" files on the MDS to see the wait+processing time of each RPC type. Cheers, Andreas -- Andreas Dilger Lustre Technical Lead Oracle Corporation Canada Inc. --
Robert Pinnow - Managing Director - r i s e | fx
t:
+49
30 201 803 00 robert
@
risefx.com
r i s e | fx GmbH |
_______________________________________________ Lustre-discuss mailing list [email protected] http://lists.lustre.org/mailman/listinfo/lustre-discuss
