Roman Turovsky wrote: Mon, 15 Aug 2005 08:00:27 -0700 > > Now that makes perfect sense. Suetin must have rejected these pieces > > as just so much garbage, enough to cause Koshkin to spread rumors > > about him and his father which would make your scurrilous writings > > like a pleasant walk in the park. Perhaps I should ask Nikita for > > permission to publish his e-mail message to me Dated Thu, 11 Jan 2001 > > 18:32:29 +0300, detailing his opinions of Suetin. I have a good > > occasion to pose him this question. I am planning to post on blog > > later today a part of your message regarding my editions as > > maculatura, and ask both Koshkin and Gilardino, composers I have > > published and whose music is included in my free bonus program, if > > the would agree that your characterization of their music as > > maculatura is acceptable to them. >Considering the whopping dozen people that read your blog: post your rotten >heart's content. Make our day.
34 people are allowed to post on my blog, and 40 have included it on their Friends List, i.e., they read it every day. Besides, this is one guitar blog that is read daily by thousands of guitarists all over the world. But all of this is besides the point. The post is intended at only two readers, Koshkin and Gilardino, the two composers on LJ whose music for the guitar I published. Your day is made. > > > > Also, your newly found love affair with Koshkin, so soon after you > > > > denounced me for publishing the music of Koshkin/Myshkin, right here > > > > in this forum, is almost a year old by now. How come it had taken him > > > > all that time to tell you about his lute compositions? > > > > Anyway, a side show of little interest. > > >Not really. At least this is lutenistically relevant, > > > > As relevant as all the other hearsay rumors we have been reading > > recently in this forum. It will become relevant when, and if, it is > > ever published, and if in fact it was ever composed, which I doubt > > very much. As one composer who has been distributing copies of his > > manuscripts years before they were submitted for publication, Koshkin > > would have surely sent you copies of his lute music as soon as you > > became his LJ friend. The fact that he did not even tell you about it > > until now, only means that it does not exist, and therefore, not > > lutenistically relevant. >Would yoy mind making a decision whether to allege EITHER non-existence OR >substandard quality. You cannot claim both at the same time. Of course I can, and I did. Knowing Suetin personally, I know well what he thinks of Koshkin, and certainly I know what Koshkin thinks of him. What exactly went on between these two 15 years ago, is not a subject that should interest many here, and if not for your knee jerk reaction to my joke about your Rorschach test responses, we would not be discussing this at all. And your next knee jerk response is... Matanya Ophee Editions Orphe'e, Inc., 1240 Clubview Blvd. N. Columbus, OH 43235-1226 Phone: 614-846-9517 Fax: 614-846-9794 mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.orphee.com http://www.livejournal.com/users/matanya/ To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
