Recently I bought a CD with symphonies and concertos by C. Ph. E. Bach by Akademie für Alte Musik Berlin. Beside that it is a superb recording, you can clearly hear the Konzertmeister (no conductor) breath sharpely e.g. in the beginning of the prestissimo. As a musician, you immediately sit upright on the edge of your chair... :-) http://www.amazon.de/Symphonies- Concertos/dp/B0012OQZZ2/ref=sr_1_13?ie=UTF8&s=music&qid=1222759274&sr=1-13
Regards, Stephan Am 29 Sep 2008 um 18:10 hat David Tayler geschrieben: > Again, without going in to names, even the edited > CDs have irregular breathing and other noises, > which of course raises the interesting question > as to why the students are asked to breathe > differently than the teachers. But maybe it is a > good idea, I have tried it over the years, but it > doesn't work for me. Paradoxically, it is very > important in voice lessons. Whn singing and > playing at the same time, I recommend that the > lute has to take second place, and I find it very > challenging to hold the instrument steady while > tanking up. I have to stand and use a strap, even > then the lute really sits on the chest. The > theorbo also puts a lot of downbearing weight on > the shoulders, even with my ultralight 3 lb instrument. > > dt > At 07:33 AM 9/29/2008, you wrote: > >Listening to BACH "Intavolatura", CD by Rolf Lislevand, you can hear his > >breathing (disturbing, IMO) and in some of POD CD too, but less disturbing I > >think... > >V. > > > >-----Message d'origine----- > >De : Eugene C. Braig IV [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > >Envoyé : lundi 29 septembre 2008 16:27 > >À : lute-cs.dartmouth.edu > >Objet : [LUTE] Re: breathing > > > > > >At 03:40 AM 9/29/2008, David Tayler wrote: > > >Just out of curiosity, I listened to to samples from various > > >recordings, especially concert recordings, since breaths are edited > > >in recordings, using a pair of headphones that I use for editing. > > >Without mentioning specifics, I can say for the majority breathing is > > >pretty random and does not follow the phrases of the music. Maybe it > > >should, but it doesn't seem to :) > > >Plenty of subvocalization as well, which of course is also edited out
