Hello Ari, 

Thanks a lot for your comments and suggestion. 

Please see my inline reply. 

> Here's some comments on draft-hex-lwig-energy-efficient-02.
> 
> In general I think this is good stuff and looking forward to seeing more 
> especially
> on how to take L2 & L1 features into account at L3 and above. Are there some
> standard APIs or such available BTW?

Sadly, not yet standard, and the chipset do provide some APIs for their own 
chipset. 

> 
> More specific comments on the text:
> 
>   As show in
>   Figure 1 below, the IETF has developed CoAP as the application layer
>   and 6LoWPAN as the adaption layer to run IPv6 over IEEE 802.15.4 and
>   Bluetooth Low-Energy,
> 
> Considering the current work at 6lo it would be good to mention 15.4 and BTLE
> are just examples of what 6LoWPAN can and will be used on. That said, focusing
> only to those two in this draft is probably a good idea.

I discussed with authors, they agree to focus on 15.4 and BTLE. 

>   Below we list the energy consumption profile of the
>   most common atom operations on a prevalent sensor node platform.
> 
> What's "atom operations"?

We meant the basic operations that are not dividable. 


>    Traffic Filtering Service (TFS): A service provided by an access
> 
> Especially since the IEEE standards are not easily accessible, a bit more 
> details on
> this would be interesting. Can one e.g., address application layer protocols 
> with
> the filters?

That's an issue. Normally the IEEE specs will be free for 6 months since 
publication. 

The TFS is a capability provided by 802.11v. e.g. it can be used to filter out 
ICMP message over the air. The Access Point sends a TFS Request to the node, 
and the node will ack and then the specified traffic will not passed from the 
infrastructure to the wireless nodes. 







_______________________________________________
Lwip mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/lwip

Reply via email to