Martin Vermeer wrote:
> Isn't that a LaTeX limitation? Implementing it as an inset in LyX
> wouldn't remove this limitation, if you insist on having it output
> \begin{commwent} \end{comment} pairs.

Certainly not. I can have something like

        \begin{comment}
        \section{First Section}
        bla bla
        \begin{table}
        \begin{tabular}{|c|c|}
        \hline
        cell 1&
        cell 2\tabularnewline
        \hline
        \end{tabular}
        \caption{a tabular}
        \end{table}
        \begin{quote}
        to be or not to be, that's the question
        \end{quote}
        an so on\ldots{}
        \end{comment}

in LaTeX but not in LyX (without ERT that is). 

> In Note OTOH you can place whatever you want inside the inset. With my

IMO you can put *anything* into the comment environment (have a look at the 
verbatim docs for details). That's why comment should be implemented as 
collapsable.

> (i.e. originally Angus' or you?) approach you can easily add new forms
> of annotation (endnote?) provided you know how they work in LaTeX. And
> you can easily change one form into another, e.g. if you decide to
> share a "blind" note with your readers in the form of a footnote.

Yes, and I really appreciate your approach. I only think that comment should 
be handled with this approach too. I guess the comment environment has been 
implemented long time before the inset idea came up, so the limitations have 
historical reasons.

Regards,
Juergen,

Reply via email to