My take is that if "justified" wasn't there I probably would have tried it. But if it actually removes paragraph formatting (even if it resorts to the default for the context) wouldn't it be clearer to say "Remove Paragraph Formatting"? I'm surmising it's doing both. So I understand the problem in the wording. And I appreciate your interest in the detail here!

The short version of why it doesn't say that is that, if there's no
special formatting, then that box will be checked to represent that
there is no special formatting. But I suppose we could change the label
depending upon which situation we're in.

I just noticed that these imported docs have some rag-right (left) formatting in them which were left over from the import, and some randomly justified paragraphs. In this case the button as labeled makes perfect sense because that's what it does.

Right. And if you have a bunch of paragraphs that are differently formatted, Default will set them all to their default, whatever that might be.

But where I ran into this was in trying to format a footnote to which I wouldn't think "justified" would apply except for the fact that the marker is in a justified paragraph.

From my view I was trying to format a footnote and get rid of an extra blank line in the footnote footer region. So it didn't occur to me that "justified" would apply to that. But maybe it does. (paragraph formatting is otherwise defined in the class?) I think that even if "justified" is correct, it was a little mis-leading -- perhaps just due to my ignorance. However the original text "Apply Paragraph's Default Alignment" by itself is accurate because it would have implied to me that it might properly format a footnote -- which it does!

In principle, a footnote could be formatted differently from the main text---though that would look quite silly. It may be that 1.6 won't allow such customization in footnotes. It probably shouldn't if it does.

Richard

Reply via email to