Hi,
Just got back from DC. It was a nice vacation trip until the security 
frights on Sunday kicked, and they starting blocking off all the 
streets around all the Fed buildings. :-(  I didn't get to be a tourist 
around the Capital, as I had originally planned, with cop cars on every 
corner blocking off all the streets. So, I ended up spending the day in 
Annapolis instead.

I missed the mac club presentation this week, but it sounded like alot 
of fun!
Just reading the this thread-

> Date: Sat, 31 Jul 2004 13:23:34 -0400 (EDT)
> From: Henri Yandell <bayard at generationjava.com>
> Subject: Re: MacGroup: Region free internal DVD?
>
> I'm not very clueful in this area, but very few seem to be. There 
> seems to
> be little demand in the US to view non Region 1 DVDs. Japanese Anime 
> seems
> the biggest area of demand, so it's not been that easy to find 
> region-free
> players.
>
> A Java/Mac user in Atlanta found a player he likes:
>
> http://jason.blog-city.com/read/542165.htm
>
> which is available at:
>
> http://www.220-electronics.com/dvd/jvc40.htm
>
> An important part is that not only must it be region-less, it has to 
> talk
> PAL/NTSC (or you have to attach something that does). Again, because of
> the lack of demand, TVs in the US are not dual-mode (as far as I know).


That is a pretty good price on that JVC, although I don't know the 
vendor. They also don't list a physical address either--only a phone 
number. Personally, I would be VERY wary of giving some online company, 
with no address, a credit card number. Be careful, some of these sites, 
have people that post notes about their products on mailing lists, in 
order to get sales, or scam you of your card numbers.

This JVC product--it appears to me, it is a modified, grey market item 
(either build for export, or not meant to be imported here for use in 
the USA). If you buy grey market electronics, they may work for you 
here, but I do know, that factory warranties become invalid here in the 
states. If you want to be sure about an online sale like this? If 
possible, get a serial number of the actual product for sale from the 
Vendor, and then call the Manuf to see if the item will be covered 
under warranty here in the USA. Be sure to ask them if it is a 
legitimate online vendor, and if it is safe to buy from them.  (I 
personally would not buy anything from this vendor--they look shady to 
me)

The shuttle astronauts used a Sony DVD player that was modified by a 
"third-party consultant" to NASA, to become region-less --obviously 
something a space travelor would need in a around the world DVD player 
and/or satellite connection! This player is not grey market--since 
essentially it is sold here in the USA. Plus, how could something that 
was built by Sony and then modified by government paid, NASA astronauts 
be "illegal"??? ;-D  Ha!  Talk about bending the law?

In regards to some of the other posts in this thread? Apple is member 
of the Computer Vendor and Hollywood technical consortium on protecting 
DVD software and film media, and thus has helped to create the 
technology for all these region-based players. This consortium has made 
copying dvd a "hassle" for you on purpose, and intentionally so, to cut 
down on internationally bootlegging of software and movies. So asking 
Apple to create DVD players that works without Region-based technology? 
This request, will fall on deaf ears.

In regards to actually copying DVDs-
In order to create movie DVDs, for use, from within or across 
geo-zones, it is not the same process at all as using a VCR burner to 
copy a movie from a player, which was an analog process, not digital. 
When you play a DVD, your player "unpacks" it, from the highly 
compressed state it was set to, by a secret formula when it was burned. 
This is a engineering recipe mix-depending on screen or audio qualities 
each studio uses dicated in part by their primary computer vendor 
partnership. (Warner (Microsoft/Apple)  vs Columbia(Sony) VS 
Disney(Apple/Sun) VS Paramount (Microsoft) VS Universal(Microsoft) etc)

On an Apple computer, dvd playback is actually held in RAM memory, then 
into Virtual memory onto your drive, which in this suspended state 
temporarily removes the geo-zoning code from it, when it is converted 
to zeros and ones. When you try to reburn this movie content to the 
same type of media format (DVD)? you won't be able to fit this data on 
to a single dvd like it came from.  The multimedia data, is now 
unpacked and in fat binary, and it can't be re-compressed again without 
the software and passkeys it originated from. In order to fit this data 
on the DVD disk ? The software consortium uses proprietary algorithms, 
in fractal geometry (endless numbers, which are harder to crack). This 
kind of code is the kind of information, they do not want you to know 
how to do this...

This is why you see unprofessional teenager bootlegs on eBay that are 
on two cds. Obvious sign it is a bootleg! Or a bootleg that is created 
from a camera recording a movie shown in a movie theater. Both methods 
make for poor copies...

All of these blocks you are having with region-based movies? Is just 
one of the blocks created to keep consumers from being able to make 
copies of both Computer maker and studio intellectual property. Of 
course --this doesn't keep oversea black marketers from getting to it, 
but they usually own their own systems. to hack it.

So, When you start talking about wanting to copy copyrighted DVD movies 
on your computer? This is not a simple question for any Developer to 
answer--especially since you are asking questions that are essentially 
are about "how to break the law". Copying DVD media, is not a "right" 
that Studios feel you have the freedom to have to their copyrighted 
Material, nor Computer Vendors, like Apple, being partner to them, want 
you be able to do either....  They want this property to stay within 
their control--not yours.

Since the older DVD movie protections, for both compression codes and 
geo player codes, have been hacked, pretty well now, things like this 
Panasonic player above, which was modified to play zone-free? These 
type of solutions are becoming very out-dated. There are some new 
piracy protective technologies in the works now. So, You may want to 
forget about buying any zone-less DVD players like this, for your 
geo-zone problem since many of those workaround methods are becoming 
obsolete anyway.

You can a little more about this work in this article here:
http://zdnet.com.com/2100-1104_2-5269286.html

Hope this helps to shed some light on this entire DVD publishing 
subject.  :-)

Yours,
Kay




| The next meeting of the Louisville Computer Society will
| be July 27. The LCS Web page is <http://www.kymac.org>.
| List posting address: <mailto:macgroup at erdos.math.louisville.edu>
| List Web page: <http://erdos.math.louisville.edu/macgroup>


Reply via email to