Hi John,
Nobody, here has anything against questions or questioning policy,
but you are definately wrong in stating that MacPorts is a "buggy
software scheme".
Quite the contrary is true. Have you used Fink? Fink has in the past
screw my entire
system big time! I have had to completely install the entire machine.
MacPort is rather non-evasive. If the software that is installs via
MacPort has bugs or if a major
incompatibility occurs I can simply remove MacPort and start from
scratch.
Also, MacPorts has evolved to become very stable. That is most problems
with MacPorts are due
to not using the system properly. That is not selfupdating and not
upgrading before a new port is installed.
Then there is the problem that of migrating a MacPorts install, I
personally hold this for a mistake, one should
migrate a MacPorts install. Yes, they have support for it, but I
discourage it.
Now, there is only two aspects that make Macports "buggy" as you say:
1) The upstream source is buggy.
2) The upstream software must be ported, aka portfiles have to be
maintained.
1) is a non-brainer.
2) Is a problems as the volunteer work is not co-ordinated, so that
every port is necessarily "in sync"
with every it depends upon.
MacPort is driven by volunteer work, and if you follow this list, you
would know that the maintainers
go way out of there way to help. Many problems that can not be solved
are upstream problem.
MacPort is cutting-edge software. Therefore, there will always be
problems, but I would call them hardly
bugs or buggy. It is development in progress. Evidently, would do work
with software that is actively being
developed very often or you would know this.
Of course this is ONLY my opinion, and probably not YOURS.
regards
Keith.
Am 05.11.2010 um 04:16 schrieb John B Brown:
> Dear Daniel,
>
> Communication is essential to learning. Asking as many questions as
> possible is one way to communicate a need for enlightenment. Posing
> possibilities is another. Asking questions can hardly be considered bombast.
> Why would you even remember my initial learning curve?
>
> I certainly do hope you have a better command of work languages; your
> command of adjectives seems distorted.
>
> And yes, debugging implies bugs. Macports are forever being debugged.
> Do you wish to claim that as my fault also?
>
> Go check your cats!
>
> Daniel J. Luke wrote:
>> On Nov 4, 2010, at 10:50 PM, John B Brown wrote:
>>> Since when has rendering an honest opinion been unacceptable?
>> You have repeatedly bombastically blamed macports for problems that end up
>> being caused by changes you've made to your system that put it into a
>> non-working state.
>> ... and now you're telling other users that macports is full of bugs.
>> That's fine (as it's fairly easy to ignore you) - but you should expect that
>> someone will step in to correct you when you offer bad advice to other users.
>> --
>> Daniel J. Luke
>> +========================================================+
>> | *---------------- [email protected] ----------------* |
>> | *-------------- http://www.geeklair.net -------------* |
>>
>> +========================================================+
>> | Opinions expressed are mine and do not necessarily |
>> | reflect the opinions of my employer. |
>> +========================================================+
>
_______________________________________________
macports-users mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.macosforge.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/macports-users
