#1911: madwifi problems with power saving STAs
-------------------------------------+--------------------------------------
Reporter: [EMAIL PROTECTED] | Owner:
Type: defect | Status: new
Priority: critical | Milestone:
Component: madwifi: driver | Version: trunk
Resolution: | Keywords: power saving
Patch_attached: 0 |
-------------------------------------+--------------------------------------
Old description:
> Hardware: Asus WL-500g Premium with TP-Link TL-WN560G card, laptop with
> Intel 3945 card, Nokia N810.
> Software: OpenWrt trunk with 2.6 kernel and MadWifi driver in AP mode,
> bridged to local network.
>
> After changing wireless card in my Asus router from broadcom to atheros I
> started to see a problems with my Nokia N810 device. It frequently
> diassociates from AP, but didn't notice that, also stopes answer to
> pings, but can answer after a series of pings requests. I started to
> investigate this situation.
>
> Facts:
>
> 1) N810 disconnects from AP by inact timeout with:
> {{{
> Apr 27 17:03:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e probe station due to inactivity
> Apr 27 17:06:21 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e probe station due to inactivity
> Apr 27 17:06:36 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e probe station due to inactivity
> Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e station timed out due to inactivity (refcnt 9)
> Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e send station deauthenticate (reason 2)
> Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e station with aid 1 leaves (refcnt 13)
> Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e node_cleanup_debug (ieee80211_node_leave2316): power
> save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
> }}}
>
> 2) N810 always answer to pings and other packets if it transmits data out
> through AP;
>
> 3) N810 works excellent if it has disabled Power Saving mode;
>
> After that I start running tcpdump on both ends (AP and N810):
>
> 4) when N810 in PS, it often didn't recieve arp broadcast from network,
> and don't answer to arp requests for it;
>
> 5) nothing changes after 'iwpriv ath0 uapsd 0', 'iwpriv ath0 wmm 0', and
> encryption set to none;
>
> Then I put my laptop in Power Saving mode:
>
> 6) with laptop I see exactly the same situation with arp requests;
>
> 7) laptop didn't deassociate from AP, because of frequent changes in PS
> mode and resetting timeout:
> {{{
> Apr 27 17:11:52 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
> Apr 27 17:11:53 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
> Apr 27 17:11:53 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
> Apr 27 17:11:54 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
> Apr 27 17:11:54 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
> }}}
>
> 8) laptop also works excellent with disabled Power Saving;
>
> To fix arp problem I added mac address to arp table of desktop computer
> in lan with permanent state. And it helps - madwifi always sends packet
> with direct address to PS STAs:
> {{{
> Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e save frame, 1 now queued
> Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 06:19:e0:8c:09:29 ieee80211_beacon_update: TIM updated, pending 1, off 0,
> len 1
> Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e recv ps-poll, send packet, queue empty
> Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e power save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
> Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 06:19:e0:8c:09:29 ieee80211_beacon_update: TIM updated, pending 0, off 0,
> len 1
> Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
> 00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
> }}}
>
> I try different versions of madwifi:
> a) r3314 with openwrt patches;
> b) r3314 without openwrt patches;
> c) r3480 without openwrt patches.
>
> All works the same. I can't at the moment try latest trunk because of
> ticket 1910, but I think that it also has this problem.
>
> I can give any logs and debugging testing if you say what you want to
> see.
New description:
Hardware: Asus WL-500g Premium with TP-Link TL-WN560G card, laptop with
Intel 3945 card, Nokia N810.
Software: !OpenWrt trunk with 2.6 kernel and MadWifi driver in AP mode,
bridged to local network.
After changing wireless card in my Asus router from broadcom to atheros I
started to see a problems with my Nokia N810 device. It frequently
diassociates from AP, but didn't notice that, also stopes answer to pings,
but can answer after a series of pings requests. I started to investigate
this situation.
Facts:
1. N810 disconnects from AP by inact timeout with:
{{{
Apr 27 17:03:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e probe station due to inactivity
Apr 27 17:06:21 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e probe station due to inactivity
Apr 27 17:06:36 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e probe station due to inactivity
Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e station timed out due to inactivity (refcnt 9)
Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e send station deauthenticate (reason 2)
Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e station with aid 1 leaves (refcnt 13)
Apr 27 17:06:51 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e node_cleanup_debug (ieee80211_node_leave2316): power
save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
}}}
2. N810 always answer to pings and other packets if it transmits data out
through AP;
3. N810 works excellent if it has disabled Power Saving mode; [[BR]]After
that I start running tcpdump on both ends (AP and N810):
4. when N810 in PS, it often didn't recieve arp broadcast from network,
and don't answer to arp requests for it;
5. nothing changes after {{{iwpriv ath0 uapsd 0}}}, {{{iwpriv ath0 wmm
0}}}, and encryption set to none;[[BR]]Then I put my laptop in Power
Saving mode:
6. with laptop I see exactly the same situation with arp requests;
7. laptop didn't deassociate from AP, because of frequent changes in PS
mode and resetting timeout:
{{{
Apr 27 17:11:52 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
Apr 27 17:11:53 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
Apr 27 17:11:53 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
Apr 27 17:11:54 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
Apr 27 17:11:54 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:18:de:b8:be:7b power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
}}}
8. laptop also works excellent with disabled Power Saving;
To fix arp problem I added mac address to arp table of desktop computer in
lan with permanent state. And it helps - madwifi always sends packet with
direct address to PS STAs:
{{{
Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e save frame, 1 now queued
Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
06:19:e0:8c:09:29 ieee80211_beacon_update: TIM updated, pending 1, off 0,
len 1
Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e recv ps-poll, send packet, queue empty
Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e power save mode off, 0 STAs in PS mode
Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
06:19:e0:8c:09:29 ieee80211_beacon_update: TIM updated, pending 0, off 0,
len 1
Apr 27 17:17:42 OpenWrt user.debug kernel: wifi0/ath0[06:19:e0:8c:09:29]:
00:1d:6e:d5:7c:7e power save mode on, 1 STAs in PS mode
}}}
I try different versions of madwifi:
a. r3314 with openwrt patches;
b. r3314 without openwrt patches;
c. r3480 without openwrt patches.
All works the same. I can't at the moment try latest trunk because of
ticket 1910, but I think that it also has this problem.
I can give any logs and debugging testing if you say what you want to see.
--
Ticket URL: <https://madwifi.org/ticket/1911#comment:4>
madwifi.org <http://madwifi.org/>
Multiband Atheros Driver for Wireless Fidelity
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by the 2008 JavaOne(SM) Conference
Don't miss this year's exciting event. There's still time to save $100.
Use priority code J8TL2D2.
http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;198757673;13503038;p?http://java.sun.com/javaone
_______________________________________________
Madwifi-tickets mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/madwifi-tickets
