On Fri, 7 Feb 2003 16:45:38 -0800 (Pacific Standard Time) "David E. Weekly" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
DEW> Before I begin, let me say that I am tremendously impressed with this piece DEW> of software, and while I'm not yet ready to switch over to its fulltime DEW> use, it's really not far off from that point. The interface is non-clunky, DEW> things are snappy, and no bad surprises so far. Hooray! Thanks! DEW> 1) Aesthetics. DEW> DEW> 1.1) When resizing the window, the window does not repaint itself. This is DEW> awkward and visually unpleasant. Sorry, which window? The main one? I don't see it here (I assume you're speaking about the Windows version, right?) except when there is no message shown in the viewer -- then there are indeed some refresh problems. I know about this but didn't have time to fix it as it's not catastrophic -- just ugly. DEW> 1.2) The carat disappears when typing text; the carat should remain solid DEW> while the user is typing. The composer widget is a disaster beyond salvage and will be replaced (probably by something less functional but maybe at least working...). DEW> 1.3) When selecting a block of text, the carat should be at the end of the DEW> selection, not the beginning. Same as above. DEW> 2) Layout DEW> DEW> 2.1) The "No recipients" bar takes up a very large amount of real estate DEW> for no apparently good reason. The interface should be small, tight, and DEW> polished. You can change the size of this zone using the splitter. Making it small is no good because when you add a few recipients you won't see them all and a scrollbar will appear. But, anyhow, it's up to you to choose the size you like and it should remember it (if it doesn't, it's a bug). DEW> 2.2) Composition windows appear to wrap text at 80 characters, but present DEW> no visual indication of the point at which this happens. Why not open a DEW> fixed-size window fixed to the maximum width of the message to be composed? DEW> This would be more elegant. DEW> DEW> 2.3) It is very easy to cause the word-wrapping engine to fail, outputting DEW> lines longer than 80 characters (simply revisit a previous line and start DEW> typing!). It may be easier to simply not do any word-wrapping at all until DEW> the message is being sent. This is what Outlook and company do. See above... DEW> 2.4) "To", "From", "CC", and "BCC" are not clearly displayed in the DEW> composition window. I must admit I quite like the current design. It is rather compact and allows to do everything quickly (from the keyboard). I don't think adding empty "Cc:" and "Bcc:" fields is a good idea. As for "From:", it used to be displayed only in "advanced" mode which you probably dind't activate but now (i.e. in the latest versions) it is displayed all the time. DEW> 3) Usability DEW> DEW> 3.1) The program would ideally retain Outlook's popular key combinations DEW> (Control-M to check new messages, Control-Enter to send a new message) to DEW> make converting to Mahogany easier. I've never used Outlook so I don't even know its key combinations. In any case, no fixed set of keys is going to satisfy everybody so it's clear that we need a way to customize them. There is even a bug report about this. Unfortunately I didn't time to get to it yet and probably won't soon. DEW> 3.2) I use IMAP over SSL, as do many IMAP users. "Using SSL" should be an DEW> option in the initial setup. You're right. There is not much place for it in the wizard unfortunately, so I'll have to do some tweaking. Could you please file a "wish report" about this in the bug tracker? DEW> 3.3) When creating a new IMAP account, the program should volunteer to DEW> download the folders for the account at that pointn. I believe that currently this happens when you try to open the IMAP folder for the first time, doesn't it? DEW> 3.4) Mahogany should also only display MAIL folders instead of every single DEW> blinking file in the user's folder. Not Mahogany fault -- it shows everything the server shows it. So this really is just a (mis)configuration of your IMAP server. DEW> 3.5) The name of the IMAP master folder should be the user's mail server DEW> name (or a user-settable name) and not "IMAP Server". Some users (like DEW> myself) havemultiple I MAP accounts. The name *is* user-settable, of course, but it's true that "IMAP server" is a bit lame. OTOH "foo.bar.baz.com IMAP server with SSL on port 7777" wouldn't be good neither. So I think you'll usually want to rename the folder anyhow... DEW> 3.6) When composing, if a new IMAP message comes in, it freezes the DEW> composition window until the new message is fully downloaded. This is very DEW> frustrating. NEVER interrupt the user. I don't have this problem (and quite a few of other ones) because I use an external editor. Of course, the only good solution for this would be to make Mahogany fully multithreaded. This is difficult. DEW> 3.7) Standard Windows editing key-combos (Shift-Delete for CUT, DEW> Shift-Insert for PASTE, Control-Insert for COPY, and Control-Z for UNDO) do DEW> not work, frustrating word processing. DEW> DEW> 3.8) Drag-n-drop text editing doesn't work (not a big deal). See above. DEW> 3.9) Dragging and dropping a file onto the composition window doesn't add DEW> it as an attachment to the message. (mildly more serious) It would be indeed nice to have this. Could you file another wish report for those? Thanks, VZ ------------------------------------------------------- This SF.NET email is sponsored by: SourceForge Enterprise Edition + IBM + LinuxWorld = Something 2 See! http://www.vasoftware.com _______________________________________________ Mahogany-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/mahogany-users
