On 3 May 2021, at 15:43, Pete Resnick wrote:

> Saw this in the release notes for Test Build 5800:
>
> - Changed: By default, MailMate no longer uses the format=flowed standard. 
> For now, it can be enabled using MmFormatFlowedEnabled if needed/preferred.
>
> Why the change? There should be more format=flowed in the world, not less, 
> IMO.

To be honest, I wanted to see if anyone cared/noticed. I'm only seeing less 
`format=flowed` in the world and it's not working well for some MailMate users. 
They may even be the majority, but they don't know why they are getting 
hard-wrapped replies when sending emails using MailMate which only require 
plain text (and therefore has no HTML part).

It's very likely I'll switch it back in some way, but I would like to find some 
kind of middleground solution which could work well for most users most of the 
time. For example, it would at least make sense to always use `format=flowed` 
for the plain text part when HTML is generated since that is unlikely to be a 
problem for most email clients (they either prefer HTML using an HTML editor or 
they have proper plain text support).

When sending plain text then it could perhaps depend on whatever MailMate knows 
about the correspondent, e.g., the email client used or the content-type 
headers seen in the past. It's tricky though since some email clients may not 
generate it while they are able to parse it. Note that Gmail (webmail) can do 
neither.

But note **I'm not trying to start a discussion on what is theoretically best 
here**. I'm only concerned about what works best in practice by default for all 
types of users. I'll make sure to provide an option to force the use of 
`format=flowed` on all outgoing emails for any users still believing the world 
will learn to embrace it. I'm not really there anymore :(

And yes, the quoted printable encoder in MailMate isn't as good as it could be 
(horrible wrapping choices).

-- 
Benny
_______________________________________________
mailmate mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.freron.com/listinfo/mailmate

Reply via email to