Mark Murphy wrote:

MM) You're quoting old testament. (MM

I'm quoting Jesus endorsing every letter of the OT.

MM) All you're doing Brian is playing games... trying to make a point which
is false. (MM

Bob asked "can you find anything evil in the philosophies attributed to
[Jesus, Moses]?"  I answered his question, and you've said nothing to show
that any statement in my answer was "false".

You said "the texts do not instruct and give example of the faithful to
commit physical acts against others".  I then quoted such an instruction in
a text purportedly written by Moses and purported endorsed to the last
letter by Jesus.  Now you just say those instructions aren't currently being
followed.  It's obvious who's playing games here.

MM) There is no equivalence between between what Christian believers are
told in their scriptures and what the followers of Muhammad and his god are
told in theirs when it comes to examples of force against unbelievers and
other matters of faith and State. That's what Bob basically said. (MM

No, it's what you (and maybe he) now wish(es) he had said.  What his actual
words did was to question whether there is "anything evil in the
philosophies attributed to" Jesus and Moses.  Do you disagree with my claim
that the answer to that question is "no"?

MM) You're an inelegant person. (MM

I guess "inelegant"here means something like "not a mind-reader" or
"concerned with truth".  :-)  

MM) I'm unsure why you're trying to make an argument against such a premise.
(MM

I'm trying to get people to say what they mean and mean what they say.   If
you want to claim that the Bible contains no "examples of force against
unbelievers" and nothing that can be construed as mandating an entanglement
between faith and State, then I'd be happy to refute those claims too, but
you'd then just change your claim again instead of acknowledging that the
earlier claims weren't quite accurate.  No thanks.

MM) There's no sense in giving any kind of defense to Jihadists or to defend
the acts of Muhammad and his followers or those who continue to commit acts
in his name in these times. (MM

There's no sense in making false claims or suggestions about Christianity in
order to criticize Islam or Islamist terrorism. Aren't they bad enough to
criticize on the basis of actual facts alone?  I'm an equal opportunity
critic of all religions.  If anybody here questioned whether there was
"anything evil" in the Koran, I'd correct him too.

How would you like it if somebody started regular postings here titled
"Latest from the moral Christians" and listed articles like those at
http://www.infidels.org/wire/category_archives/crime.html?  Any libertarian
would surely acknolwedge that Americans have throughout history suffered far
more aggression inspired by Christianity than by Islam, and I don't ever see
that lead changing hands unless a nuclear explosive is involved.

Reply via email to