Big Government, Big Fire
by Randal O'Toole 
Randal O'Toole is a senior fellow and author of the book Reforming the Forest 
Service and a recent Cato paper titled "The Perfect Firestorm: Bringing Forest 
Service Wildfire Costs Under Control."
 
The Angora Fire, which burned nearly 200 homes in South Lake Tahoe, can teach 
important lessons about wildland fire. If the Forest Service has its way, 
however, they will be the wrong lessons.
 
The official Forest Service response to the fire followed a predictable 
pattern. Forest officials claim that a century of mismanagement (by their own 
agency) allowed fuels to build up to unnatural levels, making the forests ripe 
for catastrophic fire. "There is an ungodly amount of fuel" in the Tahoe area, 
says a Forest Service ecologist.
The excess fuels story has done wonders for the Forest Service budget. Ever 
since a fire burned several hundred homes in Los Alamos in 2000, Congress has 
dumped money on wildfires. The Forest Service's total fire budget has more than 
tripled, and the biggest percentage increase has been for hazardous fuel 
treatments. Now, after spending $11 billion on fire and hazardous fuel 
treatments since 2000, we have another fire destroying hundreds of homes.
It is increasingly clear that the Forest Service strategy of treating fuels and 
aggressively suppressing almost all wildfires is the wrong approach. First, 
there are too many acres to treat. The Forest Service estimates that 70 million 
federal acres need immediate treatment and 140 million more will need it soon. 
Despite its huge budget increases, the Forest Service currently treats less 
than 3 million acres a year.
Second, treating fuels won't stop fires. The Angora Fire started in a treated 
area and about half the acres burned were recently treated. When it is hot and 
dry enough, forests will burn no matter how much fuels have been treated.
Third, the best way to protect homes is to treat the private land directly 
around the homes, not remote public lands. Forest Service fire researcher Jack 
Cohen has found that homes catch fire if they have flammable roofs or they are 
exposed to the radiant heat of trees and shrubs burning near the home.
People can protect their homes from virtually any wildfire by making them 
"firewise," including installing nonflammable roofs and planting fire-resistant 
landscaping -- such as mowed lawns and trimmed trees -- within 100 to 150 feet 
of the house. The interior of a truly firewise home can be the safest refuge in 
a serious wildland fire.
The Angora Fire backs this up. Most houses in the area were not firewise. A 
2005 review found up to half of South Tahoe homes had flammable roofs and up to 
89 percent were surrounded by hazardous vegetation. Some Tahoe landowners blame 
local planning restrictions against tree removal, but one who violated those 
rules and firewised his property says his house survived while his neighbors' 
did not.
Forest Service research says that fewer than 8 million acres of land with homes 
and other structures are at high risk of fire. More than three-fourths of those 
acres are private. Treating these acres -- and it should mostly be done with 
private money -- will protect homes; treating 70 million public forest acres 
will not.
Fortunately, many insurance companies now require owners of homes near public 
lands and other forests to make their properties fire safe. But what should be 
done about wildfire on public lands?
Most forest ecologists believe that, to restore ecosystem integrity, public 
land managers should allow more acres to burn. But the Forest Service and other 
fire agencies have suppressed 99.9 percent of wildland fires to date in 2007. 
This is not only costly; it continues to cause the same ecological damage that 
the Forest Service admits resulted from its previous policies.
Forest ecosystems vary tremendously, so there is no one right combination of 
fuel treatment, fire suppression, and wildfire. But today's highly centralized 
Forest Service responds more to national political priorities than to local 
forest conditions.
The solution is to decentralize federal forests so wildfire decisions are 
responsive to the local environment. One possibility is to contract federal 
fire management out to the states. Another is to fund public land agencies out 
of user fees rather than tax dollars.
Forest Service fire spending is out of control. That spending is not solving 
the problem. If no major institutional changes are made, far more money will go 
up in smoke, hundreds of homes will continue to burn each year, and the forests 
will remain as unhealthy as ever.
This article appeared in American Spectator on July 9, 2007.

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com 

Reply via email to