Thomas L. Knapp wrote:

TK) The central mistake of _any_ political philosophy _may_ be believing
that a large set of moral lessons which can be drawn from the interactions
of _any_ particular group will easily generalize to _all_ groups. (TK

Indeed, that's why I'm extremely suspicious of any absolutist interpretation
of an ethical principle.  Where you may see a little wiggle room in a
principle as a vice, I see it as sometimes a virtue.

TK) I reject the notion that "trolley problem" necessarily deterministically
decompresses into "to the extent that private charity fails to provide a
safety net [...]  (TK

I didn't imply that it did.  I just implied that it rebuts the idea that
having clean hands should be of absolute (or arbitrarily high) importance in
one's ethics.

Reply via email to