michael.h.wilson wrote:

MW) as far as I know no party has specifically called for an end of the
deployment of U.S. troops abroad (MW

This policy doesn't really meet my criteria -- supported by 60% of
Americans, 60% of Libertarians, not traditionally advocated by the LP, and
not advocated by any of the other top four parties.

First, the Constitution party effectively already advocates this:
"immediately terminate American military presence in all foreign countries
where such U.S. presence constitutes an invitation for this nation to become
involved in, or further participate in, foreign wars."

Second, the LP Platform has traditionally advocated this position: "End the
practice of stationing American military troops overseas. We make no
exceptions to the above."   The current Platform still says "The United
States government should return to the historic libertarian tradition of
avoiding entangling alliances, abstaining totally from foreign quarrels and
imperialist adventures".

Third, nowhere near 60% of Americans support such a position.  As of Dec
2007, only 28% of Americans said we should "withdraw all of its troops from
Iraq as rapidly as possible, starting now", and only 59% thought there
should be any timetable at all for withdrawal.  I would guess that under 25%
of Americans would agree with this position.

Finally, I seriously doubt that 60% of LP members would say we should end
all deployment of U.S. troops abroad.  60% of NatCon delegates might say
that, but I bet you wouldn't get the 67% needed for a resoluton that said
it.

So it looks like my $1000 is still up for grabs. :-)

Reply via email to