Rule #1: YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.

In reviewing Kagilaritsky's article entitled "The Logic of a Revolt" concerning 
the fighting in SE Ukraine , Louis criticized the author because he:

"...fails to make the elemental distinction between violence used by a 
colonized nationality to attain national and social liberation, and the 
violence of the settler-colonizer minority--"

I have heard Ukrainian nationalists contend that the presence of large numbers 
Russian speakers in Ukraine was the result of a settler policy pursued by the 
Soviet Union after the famine of the 1930's. I do not believe that this 
analysis holds up under historical scrutiny and I wanted to clarify this pont. 

Lou, given that you believe the Russian speaking regions of Ukraine were 
created by a policy of colonization and that those populations in Ukraine that 
speak Russian are "settlers," when did this policy of social engineering take 
place? Given the mix of peoples and cultures in Eastern Europe, I am having a 
difficult time seeing the populations of SE Ukraine as analagous to the French 
in Algeria, the Scots-Irish in Ulster, or the Boers of South Africa.
Send list submissions to: Marxism@greenhouse.economics.utah.edu
Set your options at: 

Reply via email to