New Republic
Osita Nwanevu/November 9, 2020
The Left Must Hit the Streets Again—Right Now
The Biden presidency must be greeted with a historic amount of
organizing and agitation. Otherwise, we’re done for.
Enough about Donald Trump: The opportunity to plan beyond him is among
the most important privileges the Democratic Party and the country won
last week. Unless Democrats sweep the Georgia runoffs in January,
President-elect Joe Biden will take office with a divided Congress and
beset by existential crises on all sides. Having won a general election
dominated almost entirely by matters of character and general
competence, Biden is substantively short of where he ought to be on the
issues that defined the Democratic primary and are likely to define the
next decade or more of American life. After the celebrations subside,
he’ll be met with a public that will be roiled by the forces of reaction
and dismayed by his inability to deliver the political comity and
stability he has promised them. Biden might have been the man for the
moment, but the moment might not last through spring. It is passing as
we speak.
This is the fundamental problem with debates over whether and how to
“push Biden left”: There’s no reason to believe he will be the central
agent of all that’s set to happen over the next four years, especially
if Republicans keep the Senate. Even under the strongest presidents, the
American policy regime is ultimately the handiwork of a vast
constellation of additional actors. Senators, congressmen, governors,
state legislators, mayors, judges, major corporations, civil servants
and administrators, interest and advocacy groups—each category contains
pivotal figures, spheres of influence, and reserves of independent
power. The policy fights ahead will be complex; if the reasons to expect
a wave of sweeping change were strained before the election, they are
entirely broken now. What’s needed is an approach capable of directing
activists and an engaged public toward the right pressure points on the
right issues at the right times.
What’s needed, in short, is a movement. Fortunately, and despite what
the moderates licking their wounds are telling themselves now, the left
has one. Bernie Sanders, a socialist, won nearly 10 million votes
against a field of 29 candidates in this year’s primary; in state after
state, polls established him as the preferred candidate of not only the
very young but all Democrats under the age of 45. The coalition he
crafted wasn’t large enough to win him the nomination. But it remains a
force to be reckoned with, all the same. Two months ago in
Massachusetts, a state whose centrist Republican governor boasts a
nearly 90 percent approval rating among Democrats, progressive activists
torpedoed a Kennedy Senate campaign—proof positive that the left has
muscle to throw around beyond municipal politics and urban House primaries.
But the next major elections are a while off. Activists need to devise
strategies for shaping the policymaking process in the interim, as bleak
as things seem—to plan not only for the next two to four years, but the
next two to four months. It should be obvious by now that direct action,
on a scale and at a pitch this country hasn’t seen in half a century,
will be absolutely critical. Climate, health care, inequality,
immigration, policing, reproductive freedom, the American war machine,
labor rights, our civil and democratic rights, the power and perversity
of the Republican Party as an institution: Each of these issues should
be met with a wave of organizing inspired by our remarkable past decade
in mass protest, which culminated dramatically with the demonstrations
against the killing of George Floyd earlier this year.
Two campaigns early in the decade—Occupy Wall Street on the left and the
Tea Party on the right—created narrative shifts that would ultimately
lead to transformative presidential campaigns. But we’ve also seen many
others, such as the Fight for $15, Ferguson, Parkland, and others, that
capably illustrate how important policy victories at multiple levels of
government and shifts in the policy discourse might be achieved outside
the auspices of electoral politics. It should not have been a surprise,
particularly to those who remembered or participated in the
demonstrations against the Keystone XL and Dakota Access pipelines under
the Obama administration, that an old-fashioned sit-in managed to put
the Green New Deal on the map politically in 2018. That year also saw
nearly half a million Americans participate in work stoppages, including
thousands of teachers who successfully launched strikes for pay raises
in West Virginia and Arizona, two states whose conservative Democratic
senators may hold the fate of Biden’s legislative agenda in their hands
in the event that the party prevails in Georgia.
It was fascinating, over these last few weeks of the campaign, to see
the concept of resistance solidify into something a touch more serious:
the notion that the election would not or could not be stolen if a
sufficient proportion of the public rose up against the president to
defend American democracy. The fact that this may not have been true
shouldn’t diminish the significance of a substantial segment of the
American public believing it—of millions of people taking it entirely
for granted that our institutions cannot solely be relied upon to
deliver just outcomes and that mass action can bring the system to heel.
The left, if possessed of the same faith, can become a conduit for that
energy. It would be a mistake to lean instead into a kind of demographic
triumphalism—the hope that the right torchbearer will arrive in 2024,
2028, or, God forbid, 2032 to lead an ascendant socialist majority to
victory in a presidential election. The climate crisis, for one, won’t
wait for that majority to emerge. Politics should never be practiced
with the expectation of ideal conditions. There will be no messiah. No
one will be capable of doing more for us than we’ve already made
possible by our own hands. We should believe in no one more than we
believe in ourselves. And our work—organization, agitation,
action—should begin this very second. There’s no time to lose.
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group.
View/Reply Online (#3437): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/3437
Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/78206126/21656
-=-=-
POSTING RULES & NOTES
#1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
#2 This mail-list, like most, is publicly & permanently archived.
#3 Subscribe and post under an alias if #2 is a concern.
-=-=-
Group Owner: [email protected]
Unsubscribe: https://groups.io/g/marxmail/leave/8674936/1316126222/xyzzy
[[email protected]]
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
