On 06-May-99, Oliver Wagner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

>> news.software.readers, <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>> (it started before that article, but because of MD-II, I can't
>> trace it further back).
>> "Re: More bad References headers (was: Re: The C64 was crap!)"

>a) The assertion that MD-2 would include "In-Reply-To:" in news
>articles is wrong and based on a wrong observation (it's not
>the fault of the writer of that article, though). 
[...]
>This is simply a misunderstanding.

Yes. Looks like he just cut and pasted some headers from the post
in his spool-dir, not from a downloaded one.

>b) Whether retaining just a single backreference can be
>considered a bug or not is debatable.

>The tree structure of articles can be reproduced
>easily with just a single backlink per node, as (not only)
>MD-2 shows quite well. Adding a complete backlog in every
>message just means adding redundant information and wasting
>bandwidth (in a worse way than excessive .sigs, because it's
>not under user control).

>So, in net.sheriff speak, having one back reference per message
>can be considered "a reasonable number of backwards references"
>(RFC 1036), as it contains all information which is required.

>Every threaded mail reader, btw, manages to build a thread list
>solely with a single backlink, the one from In-Reply-To.

The difference, and the problem, with news is that it's lossy;
you can't count on all messages reaching you and you can't count
on them arriving in an 'orderly fashion' either, so there will often
be missing posts in a thread. Or posts that first show up after you've
seen the replies to them.
All the abusive cancelbots that are currently active don't help much
either; in some groups large parts of a thread can be missing.
So there has to be more than one ID in References in order to build
the tree. It's the safest, at least.

>However, for the sake of good net citizenship with news reading
>software which is not able to build a proper reference tree on
>it's own, I'm probably going to change this in the next MD-2
>release <sigh>

That would be utterly great.

>c) There is in fact a lame bug in the current MD-2 (including
>1.3) which causes References/In-Reply-To:  to be lost when a user
>manually edits a message before posting/sending it.  Sorry
>for that, I'll fix it immediately.

Yes, that's the most serious error right now, especially with the
new(ish) 'Store' function. If you use that, references will be lost
every time (and if you don't use it, it's sort of pointless).


Rasmus.

________________________________________________________________
MicroDot-II Mailing List - Info & Archive: http://www.vapor.com/
For Listserver Help: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "HELP"
To Unsubscribe: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "UNSUBSCRIBE"

Reply via email to