> Is it possible to scientifically measure the difference in sound quality 
> between a CD and an MD?

Yes it actually is ... each is a different wave form.  But what counts is whether
we hear a difference. 

>  All these claims made by "golden" ears who can hear 
> the difference between a CD and an MD may be purely subjective to personal 
> tastes. 

Although it's a while ago since I wrote it .. check out 
http://www.minidisc.org/format_comparison.html.   I firmly
believe you can tell the difference between ATRAC 4.5 MD and CD ...
BUT "only" on certain pieces of music and "only" using A/B switching.

With ATRAC 3.0 you don't need A/B switching.

For those that flash back to this article .... I'll admit using Xing for
the MP3 encoding was not the best option at the time ... but
MD still kicks MP3's arse anyday with any MP3 encoder at 128bit rate.   

> Does anyone on this list have an audio system that costs nearly as 
> much as your house and still use MD? I wonder what these MD using 
> audiophiles have to say...

Not worth as much as my house .. but the whole system is worth over $25,000.
And I use MD *extensively* .... CD is my preferred medium ... but MD has
completely taken over Compact Cassette for me (and to a lesser extent LP).

Long Live MD.  :)


Cheers   GC


-----------------------------------------------------------------
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
"unsubscribe" to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to