YouTube, Viacom agree to mask viewer data

Jul 15, 2008  11:51 AM (ET)

By ANICK JESDANUN
Associated Press

http://apnews.myway.com//article/20080715/D91UCGL8A.html


NEW YORK (AP) - In a nod to privacy complaints, Viacom Inc. won't be told 
the identities of individuals who watch video clips on the popular 
video-sharing site YouTube.

Viacom and other copyright holders have agreed to let YouTube mask user IDs 
and Internet addresses when Google Inc.'s online video site hands over 
viewership records in a $1 billion lawsuit accusing YouTube of enabling 
copyright infringement. A federal judge ordered the database produced in a 
July 1 ruling widely criticized by privacy activists.

"We remain committed to protecting your privacy and we'll continue to fight 
for your right to share and broadcast your work on YouTube," the company 
said in a blog posting late Monday disclosing the agreement.

Viacom is seeking at least $1 billion in damages from Google, saying 
YouTube built its business by infringing copyrights on Viacom shows, which 
include Comedy Central's "The Daily Show with Jon Stewart" and 
Nickelodeon's "SpongeBob SquarePants" cartoon.

U.S. District Judge Louis L. Stanton had dismissed privacy concerns as 
speculative when he authorized full access to the YouTube viewer logs. 
Viacom and other plaintiffs argued that they need the data to show whether 
their copyright-protected videos are more heavily watched than amateur clips.

The YouTube database includes information on when each video gets played. 
Attached to each entry is each viewer's unique login ID and the Internet 
Protocol, or IP, address for that viewer's computer - identifiers that, 
while seemingly anonymous, can often be traced to specific individuals, or 
at least their employers or hometowns.

But lawyers for Viacom and the other plaintiffs signed an agreement with 
YouTube on Monday saying they would accept measures to help YouTube 
preserve the anonymity of the records. Under the agreement, YouTube can 
swap the user logins and IP addresses with other, presumably anonymous 
signifiers; YouTube has a week to propose its method.

Viacom's lawsuit has been combined with a similar case filed by a British 
soccer league and other parties. Louis Solomon, a lawyer for those 
plaintiffs, said Google has long described records like IP address as "not 
private," and with the agreement, "we have managed to put to bed a 
non-issue." Viacom had no comment.

The masked database will still have to let the plaintiffs determine which 
individual watched which clip and when, but the records will cloak cases in 
which an existing identifier contains personally identifiable information - 
such as first initial and full last name in a user ID.

In limited circumstances, it may still be possible to track records to a 
specific individual based on that person's viewing habits. Time Warner 
Inc.'s AOL discovered that when it released to academic researchers some 19 
million search requests made over three months. AOL substituted numeric IDs 
for the subscribers' real user names, yet the disclosure of what people had 
searched for produced enough clues to track down some of the users and 
identify them.

"It's better than providing that information without that substitution, but 
I don't think it addresses the privacy concerns by a long shot," said Wendy 
Seltzer, a fellow at Harvard University's Berkman Center for Internet and 
Society.

For example, someone might be frequently viewing videos of themselves or 
the bands they are in. Even with anonymous identifiers, Seltzer said, that 
person can still be linked to other clips they watch.

She said Google and YouTube ought to reconsider whether to even retain the 
data.

The YouTube data would not be publicly released, but disclosed only to the 
plaintiffs, likely under a court-sanctioned confidentiality order. Viacom 
also has pledged not to use the data to identify individual users to sue.

Still in dispute is whether YouTube would be able to make viewing records 
on its own employees anonymous as well. If a YouTube employee had viewed an 
episode of "The Daily Show," for instance, Viacom could argue that YouTube 
directly knew of copyright infringement. And that could dissolve the 
immunity protections that service providers generally have when they merely 
host content submitted by their users.


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to