Former GM CEO Stempel On the Future of Electric Cars
Almost 20 Years After He Approved the EV1 The Same Major Snag Remains: 
Batteries

By Joseph B. White
Wall Street Journal

July 21, 2008

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB121640867386365903.html?mod=hps_us_editors_picks


One of the Big Ideas that's gotten a boost from the recent oil price shock 
is the notion that the energy for transportation should come from the 
electric grid, not an oil well in the Middle East.

A number of big, established car makers have announced plans to produce 
cars that will pull from the electric grid all or part of the energy needed 
to make them go. They join a flock of upstart companies, such as Tesla 
Motors, trying to prosper by defining a new generation of mobility 
technology starting with a blank sheet of paper – or rather a blank video 
display screen.

For everyone excited about electrifying the morning commute, Robert C. 
Stempel, the former chairman and chief executive officer of General Motors 
Corp., has a few sobering words.

Mr. Stempel believes in the idea of electric-drive cars – he uses the term 
"electric drive" to encompass both all-electric systems and plug-in 
hybrids. He gave the greenlight to development of GM's EV1, the first 
electric car to be offered by a mainstream car maker since the early years 
of the 20th Century. After he was pushed out of GM by a boardroom coup 
during the auto maker's last big financial crisis in 1992, Mr. Stempel 
continued to devote himself to the electric car idea. He spent more than a 
decade as chairman of U.S. battery maker Energy Conversion Devices, Inc. 
before leaving the company last year.

At both GM and at Energy Conversion Devices, Mr. Stempel's efforts to make 
a profitable business out of electric vehicles hit numerous potholes. GM 
has taken flak for killing the EV1. Mr. Stempel, who was long gone when the 
plug was pulled, says there was no subterfuge involved.

"The business side of the case wasn't there. The EV1 was too expensive…We 
were way off the cost target," he says.

Mr. Stempel, now a consultant with an office in suburban Detroit, says the 
obstacle to mass production of electric vehicles is the same issue as it 
was "when Mr. Edison told Mr. Ford that in a year he'd have a battery for 
his car. The weak link is the battery."

Nickel metal hydride (NiMH) batteries have proven reliable, he says. "It 
doesn't do anything naughty, like burn up," he says. But NiMH batteries 
don't have the range to be competitive with conventional cars.

Lithium-ion battery technology, similar to that used in laptop computers, 
offers better range from smaller, lighter packages. But lithium-ion 
batteries do have a propensity to be naughty. The Tesla Roadster uses 
lithium-ion batteries similar to those used in laptops. Tesla's important 
technology idea isn't the commodity batteries. It's the systems Tesla 
engineers designed to assure they stay cool and under control.

Piling thousands of laptop batteries into a car creates "a control 
nightmare," Mr. Stempel worries.

Then there's the issue of cost.

"Look at what happened to the cost of nickel," says Mr. Stempel. "The price 
of nickel has gone off the charts." A lot of the commodities used in 
batteries have gotten expensive in the recent commodity price boom, he says.

None of this necessarily means the auto industry should once again give up 
on electric-drive cars. When it comes to reducing the economy's dependence 
on oil, the amount Americans burn up in cars isn't one issue. It is THE 
issue. But consumers need to take the latest flurry of press releases 
touting forthcoming electric-drive vehicle models with a few grains of salt.

The petroleum-fueled internal combustion engine has dominated automotive 
transportation for a century for a good reason: On the basis of power per 
dollar, it's more cost effective than the competition. Depending on how 
strictly one controls the emissions, Mr. Stempel says, a gasoline fueled 
car can be five to ten times more efficient on a dollars per horsepower 
basis than an electric car.

The challenges confronting the drive to electrify automobiles point to a 
big question underlying the current energy debate in America: How much 
faith should we have in technology to bail us out?

Forget Democrats vs. Republicans. When it comes to the future of cars, it's 
Technologists vs. Skeptics. Technologists believe that innovations in 
battery technology, hydrogen storage, cellulosic ethanol production, 
water-to-hydrogen systems, and lightweight vehicle design are right around 
the corner – thanks in part to the digital revolution of the late 20th Century.

Technologists acknowledge the cost hurdles confronting alternatives to oil, 
but insist they will be overcome just as they were for the personal computer.

Skeptics believe that the technology to substantially displace oil-fired 
mobility will take years, maybe decades to develop to commercial scale at 
reasonable costs.

They also question who will come up with the billions in research and 
development capital to make cars like the Chevrolet Volt or the next 
generation of Tesla cars vehicles that ordinary people can afford. That's 
particularly relevant when it comes to Detroit's Three struggling car 
makers – who inconveniently tend to run out of money in the middle of the 
oil price shocks that refocus their minds on alternatives to oil. GM last 
week announced it's slashing its capital spending budget to ride out the 
cash crisis caused by the collapse in sales of its fuel-thirstiest trucks.

The only thing worse than the current situation, would be a sudden collapse 
in the price of oil. In the absence of incentives to pay the price for new 
technology, consumers could strand expensive electric vehicles on dealer lots.

"I'm glad I am not an automotive CEO right now," says Mr. Stempel. "I 
thought I had problems."


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to