The following article is forwarded to you by the DBTAC-Great Lakes ADA
Center (www.adagreatlakes.org) for your information:

Library Journal
August 15, 2008

Digital Discrimination
Ten years after Section 508, libraries still fall short of addressing
disabilities online
By Jim Blansett -- Library Journal

In recent years, the Internet has become a digital commons of commerce and
education. However, accessibility standards have often been overlooked
online, and the digital equivalents to curb-cuts and other physical
accommodations have only rarely been implemented to serve those with print
disabilities. (A print disability can be a learning disability, a visual
impairment, or a physical disability. Individuals diagnosed with a print
disability cannot access print in the standard way).

Most librarians are aware of disability legislation such as the Americans
with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA). But while this piece of legislation, a
civil rights law, has gone far to prohibit discrimination against people
with disabilities, the extent of web use today had not yet been considered
when the ADA was enacted nearly 20 years ago. As such, the ADA does not
specifically address the increasingly important sphere of information
technology. The ADA requires that places of public accommodation and the
services they provide be accessible, but there's no specific reference to
the Internet as a place of public accommodation and service for individuals
with disabilities. This is where Section 508 of the U.S. Code comes in, and
a recent study of how well libraries adhere to the standards it sets shows
that they are not yet fully in compliance (see the sidebar on page 28 for
the history of Section 508).

How libraries are doing

To further understand accessibility in higher education and libraries, David

Comeaux and Alex Schmetzke of the University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point have

kept an eye on library and information science (LIS) schools and their
library web sites. Their 2006 research provides insight into how accepting
these schools and their libraries are of web page standards. The researchers

found inroads in web page accessibility among LIS schools and library web
sites but also found continued barriers. They looked at 56 American Library
Association (ALA)-accredited LIS school web pages and the pages of those
schools' libraries, following up on Schmetzke's 2002 investigation of the
same sites. The 2006 findings indicate that from 2002 to 2006, percentages
of web pages that were accessible went up, and the number of errors per page

went down. The average number of hurdles faced by users with disabilities in

2006 was half what it had been four years earlier.

Despite these improvements, however, only 47 percent of LIS schools and 60
percent of their libraries were fully accessible in terms of W3C web
accessibility guidelines. Comeaux and Schmetzke suggest that if the more
stringent Section 508 standards were taken into consideration, this
percentage would be even lower, because many sites do not provide the
requisite "skip-navigation" links. Such links allow people who use screen
readers or navigate by keyboard only, to navigate web pages more
successfully. Without them, the screen reader will go to the top of the page

each time a new page loads into the browser, requiring all of the previous
content to be read again. This makes it difficult and time-consuming to
navigate multilevel sites and get to the main content. In addition, sighted
users who do not use a mouse may be required to use dozens of keystrokes to
tab through every link in sequence. These links are a level two priority for

W3C web accessibility guidelines, which means that providing these links
"should" be accomplished, rather than "must be" accomplished. Section 508,
on the other hand, promotes "skip navigation" as an important priority.

Unfortunately, the understanding of Section 508 standards is not widespread.

Because these standards are not mandatory, well-intentioned novices can
create businesses without knowing how to implement accessible web design.
Recently, individuals from the Alabama Library Association worked with a
contractor to design and construct a new web presence that would meet
Section 508 standards. The contractor, who was not familiar with these
standards, was referred to online resources for instruction. When the site
was finished, a quick check found a few errors, which were easily corrected.

With accessibility for all in mind throughout development, the library
association was able to create a beautiful, and accessible, web presence,
and the contractor gained new skills that could be used on other projects.

The Section 508 report card

Has Section 508 rippled throughout the public and private sectors? Yes and
no. The effects of Section 508 have been felt, but the wave has been slow
and gentle, barely touching certain areas. Its overall effectiveness has yet

to be determined, and there are still many factors preventing total
compliance.

Regarding government technology, Paul Jaeger, a staunch advocate of IT
accessibility, suggests that some agencies consider Section 508 to be an
unfunded mandate. Additionally, the section's requirements have often been
misinterpreted. One common impression is that obtaining accessibility
requires a costly installation of new assistive technology. However, this is

generally untrue since most corrections are easily accomplished. For
example, the most often cited error is not providing alternative text for a
picture on the web page. Creating descriptive text can be done in very
little time. In a class I taught on accessible distance education,
participants were able to learn and incorporate this task in less than 15
minutes. And yet, such phantom transition costs have caused both government
agencies and other organizations to drag their feet in meeting this mandate.

Now, the momentum seems to be shifting.

In the library industry, for example, many online content providers have
seen the handwriting on the wall. Providers such as EBSCO, Gale, and Thomson

have revised the accessibility statements on their web sites. EBSCO states
that its web site has been enhanced to exceed 508 compliance standards and
has assured customers that this full compliance will carry over into its new

EBSCOhost 2.0 interface. Gale says that it is steadily working toward
Section 508 standards, while Thomson indicates that its pages have been
reviewed recently and found to meet current Section 508 standards.

Section 508 is clearly impacting businesses in the library and information
sphere, but not all sectors are following suit. Large national companies
with major online presences fall on both sides of the accessibility divide.

Boomers & accessibility = big business

In a June 13, 2001, interview in BusinessWeek, Microsoft mogul Steve Ballmer

discussed his commitment to accessibility, claiming he wants to "do the
right thing." That Section 508 affects his largest customer, the federal
government, has definitely gotten his attention. Looking down the road,
Ballmer envisions an aging baby boom generation that may well face
challenges of reduced dexterity, vision, and hearing. So, no doubt,
accessibility makes good business sense, too.

Adobe has also been working to provide accessibility features, including a
built-in voice synthesizer in its free PDF reader for individuals who
benefit from having text read to them.

IBM has also taken up the gauntlet with its Social Accessibility Project.
Its web site, at alphaWorks Services, promotes "a service that enables
accessibility through collaborative authoring of metadata." According to an
article by Jacqui Cheng for Ars Technica (IBM508.notlong.com), the project's

goal is to provide a server where volunteers can create and publish metadata

about accessible resources that will then be used to create accessible web
pages without altering the original page code. That is certainly progress!

As market pressures align with accessibility goals, more and more software
manufacturers are likely to provide accessibility features for all of their
products, but others still need more than a gentle prod.

Battling Target for online accessibility

There have been several court cases, such as those involving America Online,

Bank of America, and Priceline, provoked by web site inaccessibility. All of

these were settled out of court, but Target, one of the nation's largest
online retail sites, seems to have something to prove: mainly, that ADA laws

shouldn't apply to its Internet presence.

A lawsuit brought by the National Federation of the Blind against Target,
filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California,
charged that Target's web site is inaccessible to the blind in violation of
the ADA, the California Unruh Civil Rights Act, and the California Disabled
Persons Act. Target filed a motion to dismiss and held that federal and
state civil rights laws do not apply to web sites like target.com, but the
case proceeded to trial.

On October 2, 2007, a federal district court judge issued two landmark
decisions. First, the court certified the Target case as a class action on
behalf of blind Internet users throughout the country under the ADA. Second,

the court held that web sites such as target.com are required by California
law to be accessible. These decisions are considered a tremendous step
forward in increasing accessibility requirements for all web sites.

Making library web pages accessible

Many who develop web sites are unaware of the simple corrections that would
make a web site accessible. Comeaux and Schmetzke's findings concerning the
discrepancies in the accessibility of LIS program web sites versus their own

library web sites can be explained by library schools perhaps taking
advantage of inexperienced graduate students without the know-how to produce

accessible web page design, while library sites are built by those with more

experience. If institutions take accessibility seriously, their web
developers will, too.

Over five years ago, Cheryl Kirkpatrick championed the idea of accessibility

when she explained in the January 2003 issue of Computers in Libraries that
by complying with Section 508 standards, librarians would be getting the
bargain of "two for the price of one: Accessibility and usability." She
pointed out the beauty of these standards is that they offer more uniform,
easier-to-navigate web pages that work with both old and new software, small

monitors, and slow Internet connections.

The need to make library web pages accessible is finally being taken
seriously. Several serious efforts guide the way. The New York Public
Library (NYPL), for example, has provided a web site that invites other
libraries to "steal" its information and use it as their own. NYPL converts
the latest standards and best practices into lessons and examples for other
libraries to use. It also offers several free software programs to measure
compliance with Section 508 accessibility standards.

Another excellent resource for web accessibility is WebAIM (Web
Accessibility in Mind) created by Utah State University. This site offers
the latest, most up-to-date information for those interested in providing
accessible web pages and web content.

Equal access for all

The practice of using Section 508 standards is slowly but surely being
adopted, but there is still much work to be done. Librarians have always
stood up for the rights of those who use their services. This is one more
arena where librarians can insist on equal access for all-others will follow

their example. While Section 508 may not apply in a strict legal sense to
your library, compliance is good general policy. The effects of Section 508
are being felt by everyone. Because of this single federal procurement law,
the benefits of the Internet may soon be shared equally.


Source:  www.libraryjournal.com


-------------------------------------------------------
Amateur Radio Operator
Duane Whittingham - N9SSN
Skywarn, ARES, SATERN
City of Chicago CERT Member
Red Cross Disaster Services Technology Member
Red Cross ECRV Certified 

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to