Biologists on the Verge of Creating New Form of Life
By Alexis Madrigal 
http://blog.wired.com/wiredscience/2008/09/biologists-on-t.html

A team of biologists and chemists is closing in on bringing non-living
matter to life.

It's not as Frankensteinian as it sounds. Instead, a lab led by Jack
Szostak, a molecular biologist at Harvard Medical School, is building
simple cell models that can almost be called life.

Szostak's protocells are built from fatty molecules that can trap bits
of nucleic acids that contain the source code for replication. Combined
with a process that harnesses external energy from the sun or chemical
reactions, they could form a self-replicating, evolving system that
satisfies the conditions of life, but isn't anything like life on earth
now, but might represent life as it began or could exist elsewhere in
the universe. 

While his latest work remains unpublished, Szostak described preliminary
new success in getting protocells with genetic information inside them
to replicate at the XV International Conference on the Origin of Life in
Florence, Italy, last week. The replication isn't wholly autonomous, so
it's not quite artificial life yet, but it is as close as anyone has
ever come to turning chemicals into biological organisms.

"We've made more progress on how the membrane of a protocell could grow
and divide," Szostak said in a phone interview. "What we can do now is
copy a limited set of simple [genetic] sequences, but we need to be able
to copy arbitrary sequences so that sequences could evolve that do
something useful."

By doing "something useful" for the cell, these genes would launch the
new form of life down the Darwinian evolutionary path similar to the one
that our oldest living ancestors must have traveled. Though where
selective pressure will lead the new form of life is impossible to know.

"Once we can get a replicating environment, we're hoping to
experimentally determine what can evolve under those conditions," said
Sheref Mansy, a former member of Szostak's lab and now a chemist at
Denver University.

Protocellular work is even more radical than the other field trying to
create artifical life: synthetic biology. Even J. Craig Venter's work to
build an artificial bacterium with the smallest number of genes
necessary to live takes current life forms as a template. Protocell
researchers are trying to design a completely novel form of life that
humans have never seen and that may never have existed.

Over the summer, Szostak's team published major papers in the journals
Nature and the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that go a
long way towards showing that this isn't just an idea and that his lab
will be the first to create artificial life -- and that it will happen
soon.

"His hope is that he'll have a complete self-replicating system in his
lab in the near future," said Jeffrey Bada, a University of California
San Diego chemist who helped organize the Origin of Life conference.

Modern life is far more complex than the simple systems that Szostak and
others are working on, so the protocells don't look anything like the
cells that we have in our bodies or Venter's genetically-modified E.
coli.

"What we're looking at is the origin of life in one aspect, and the
other aspect is life as a small nanomachine on a single cell level,"
said Hans Ziock, a protocellular researcher at Los Alamos National
Laboratory.

Life's function, as a simple nanomachine, is just to use energy to
marshal chemicals into making more copies of itself.

"You need to organize yourself in a specific way to be useful," Ziock
said. "You take energy from one place and move it to a place where it
usually doesn't want to go, so you can actually organize things."

Modern cells accomplish this feat with an immense amount of molecular
machinery. In fact, some of the chemical syntheses that simple plants
and algae can accomplish far outstrip human technologies. Even the most
primitive forms of life possess protein machines that allow them to
import nutrients across their complex cell membranes and build the
molecules that then carry out the cell's bidding.

Those specialized components would have taken many, many generations to
evolve, said Ziock, so the first life would have been much simpler.

What form that simplicity would have taken has been a subject of intense
debate among origin of life scientists stretching back to the pioneering
work of David Deamer, a professor emeritus at UC-Santa Cruz.

What most researchers agree on is that the very first functioning life
would have had three basic components: a container, a way to harvest
energy and an information carrier like RNA or another nucleic acid.

Szostak's earlier work has shown that the container probably took the
form of a layer of fatty acids that could self-assemble based on their
reaction to water (see video). One tip of the acid is hydrophilic,
meaning it's attracted to water, while the other tip is hydrophobic.
When researchers put a lot of these molecules together, they circle the
wagons against the water and create a closed loop.

These membranes, with the right mix of chemicals, can allow nucleic
acids in under some conditions and keep them trapped inside in others.  

That opens the possibility that one day, in the distant past, an
RNA-like molecule wandered into a fatty acid and started replicating.
That random event, through billions of evolutionary iterations,
researchers believe, created life as we know it.

In a paper released this month in the Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, Mansy and Szostak showed that the special
membranes, fat bubbles essentially, were stable under a variety of
temperatures and could have manipulated molecules like DNA through
simple thermal cycling, just like scientists do in PCR machines.

The entire line of research, though, begs the question: where would DNA,
or any other material carrying instructions for replication, have come
from?

Many researchers have tried to tackle this problem of how RNA- or
DNA-like molecules could have developed from the amino acids present on
the early Earth. John Sutherland, a chemist at the University of
Manchester, published a paper last year demonstrating one plausible way
that RNA could have spontaneously been created in the prebiotic world. 

Once such molecules existed, Szostak's lab's demonstrated in a Nature
paper earlier this summer that nucleic acids could replicate inside a
protocell (pdf).

But while many scientists agree the protocell work is impressive, not
every scientist is convinced that it contributes to a reasonable
explanation for the origin of life.

"Their work is wonderful inasmuch as what they are doing can be," said
Mike Russell, a geochemist with the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in
Pasadena, California. "It's just that I'm uneasy about the significance
of it to the origin of life."

Russell argues that the very first life-like molecules on Earth would
have been based on inorganic compounds. Instead of a fatty acid
membrane, Russell argues that iron sulfide could have provided the
necessary container for early cells.

But UCSD's Bada pointed out that it as unlikely we will ever know how
life actually began.

"[Szostak's] point, and how we all view it, is that it's a nice model,
but it doesn't necessarily mean that it happened that way," he said.

Szostak suggested that even if life could theoretically or did begin
some other way, his lab's hypothesis was (at least) experimentally
plausible.

"We're now pretty much convinced that growth and division could occur
under perfectly reasonable prebiotic conditions in a way that is not
some artificial laboratory construction," he said.

And actually, the most intriguing possibility of all may be that the
protocells in Szostak's lab do not closely model earthly life's origins.
If that's true, human beings, ourselves the product of evolution from
the most primitive organisms, would have created an alternative path to
imbuing matter with the properties of life.

"What we have in biology is just one of many, many possibilities,"
Szostack said. "One of the things that always comes up when people talk
about life and universal qualities is water. But is water really
necessary? What if we could design a system that works in something
else?"

Greg Williams

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to