Committee amends, approves "enormous gift" to Big Content

By Julian Sanchez  | Published: September 11, 2008 - 06:25PM CT

http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20080911-committee-amends-approves-enormous-gift-to-big-content.html

The Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights Act of 2008, which was 
blasted by consumer groups and library associations this week as an 
"enormous gift" to the content industry, won the approval of the Senate 
Judiciary Committee this afternoon by a 14-4 vote. As first reported by 
Ars this morning, a series of amendments were added during committee 
mark-up, providing privacy safeguards for records seized under the law 
and stripping away several controversial provisions—though not the hotly 
contested section empowering the Justice Department to litigate civil 
infringement suits on behalf of IP owners.

One significant change to the proposed legislation addressed, at least 
in some small measure, a concern broached by Public Knowledge and other 
consumer groups in a letter to the Judiciary Committee yesterday. Though 
the amended bill still creates expanded provisions for civil forfeiture 
of property implicated in an IP infringement case—potentially including 
servers or storage devices containing the personal data of large numbers 
of innocent persons—lawmakers altered the bill's language to 
affirmatively require a court to issue a protective order "with respect 
to discovery and use of any records or information that has been 
impounded," establishing "procedures to ensure that confidential, 
private, proprietary, or privileged information contained in such 
records is not improperly disclosed or used." They did not, however, go 
so far as to immunize the data of "virtual bystanders" from seizure, as 
the letter had requested.

The forfeiture section was also modified to exclude, as grounds for 
seizure, the violation of the "anticircumvention" provisions of the 
Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The old language would have allowed 
for forfeiture of tools that could be used to circumvent digital rights 
management software.
Excised, as well, was language that would have barred the 
"transshipment" through the United States of IP infringing goods. Since 
different countries have different IP rules, this language would 
potentially have defined goods that were legal in both their country of 
origin and their final destination—because, for instance, differences in 
copyright terms allowed works to fall into the public domain overseas 
while still under copyright in the US—as contraband.

The amendments also added a seat for a representative of the Food and 
Drug Administration, as well as any "such other agencies as the 
President determines to be substantially involved in the efforts of the 
Federal Government to combat counterfeiting and piracy" on the 
"interagency intellectual property enforcement advisory committee" that 
the bill would create.

Two new provisions were tacked on to the end of the law. The first 
directs the Comptroller General to conduct a study of the impact of 
piracy on domestic manufacturers and develop recommendations for 
improving the protection of IP in manufactured goods. (Wouldn't it be 
better to do this sort of thing before enacting enforcement legislation?)

The second is a nonbinding "sense of congress" resolution stipulating 
that, while "effective criminal enforcement of the intellectual property 
laws against such violations in all categories of works should be among 
the highest priorities of the Attorney General," the AG should give 
priority, in cases of software piracy, to cases of "willful theft of 
intellectual property for purposes of commercial advantage or private 
financial gain," especially those "where the enterprise involved in the 
theft of intellectual property is owned or controlled by a foreign 
enterprise or other foreign entity." Which is to say, that copy of 
Photoshop you pulled off BitTorrent last week isn't on the top of the 
Justice Department's docket... yet.

Remaining intact was language that would give the Justice Department 
authority to pursue civil suits against IP infringers, awarding any 
damages won to the patent, copyright, or trademark holders. Critics have 
blasted this provision as a gift of free, taxpayer-funded legal services 
to content owners. The bill now goes to the full Senate, and must still 
be recognized with its counterpart legislation in the House, which lacks 
the language deputizing the DoJ to bring suit on behalf of IP owners.
*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to