Conflict Over Spying Led White House to Brink

By Barton Gellman
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, September 14, 2008; A01

This is the first of two stories adapted from "Angler: The Cheney 
Vice Presidency," to be published Tuesday by Penguin Press. Original 
source notes are denoted in [brackets] throughout.

A burst of ferocity stunned the room into silence. No other word for 
it: The vice president's attorney was shouting.
"The president doesn't want this! [1] You are not going to see the 
opinions. You are out . . . of . . . your . . . lane!"
Five government lawyers had gathered around a small conference table 
in the Justice Department command center. Four were expected. David 
S. Addington, counsel to Vice President Cheney, got wind of the 
meeting and invited himself.
If Addington smelled revolt, he was not far wrong. Unwelcome 
questions about warrantless domestic surveillance had begun to find 
their voice.
Cheney and his counsel would struggle for months to quash the legal 
insurgency. By the time President Bush became aware of it, his No. 2 
had stoked dissent into flat-out rebellion. The president would face 
a dilemma, and the presidency itself a historic test. Cheney would 
come close to leading them off a cliff, man and office both [2].
On this second Monday in December 2003, Addington's targets were a 
pair of would-be auditors from the National Security Agency. He had 
displeasure to spare for their Justice Department hosts.
Perfect example, right here. A couple of NSA bureaucrats breeze in 
and ask for the most sensitive documents in the building. And Justice 
wants to tell them, Help yourselves? This was going to be a very 
short meeting.
Joel Brenner and Vito Potenza, the two men wilting under Addington's 
wrath, had driven 26 miles from Fort Meade, the NSA's eavesdropping 
headquarters in Maryland. They were conducting a review of their 
agency's two-year-old special surveillance operation. They already 
knew the really secret stuff [3]: The NSA and other services had been 
unleashed to turn their machinery inward, collecting signals 
intelligence inside the United States. What the two men didn't know 
was why the Bush administration believed the program was legal.
It was an awkward question. Potenza, the NSA's acting general 
counsel, and Brenner, its inspector general, were supposed to be the 
ones who kept their agency on the straight and narrow. That's what 
Cheney and their boss, Lt. Gen. Michael V. Hayden, told doubters 
among the very few people who knew what was going on. Cheney, who 
chaired briefings for select members of Congress, said repeatedly 
that the NSA's top law and ethics officers -- career public servants 
-- approved and supervised the surveillance program.
That was not exactly true, not without one of those silent asterisks 
that secretly flip a sentence on its tail. Every 45 days, after 
Justice Department review, Bush renewed his military order for 
warrantless eavesdropping. Brenner and Potenza told Hayden that the 
agency was entitled to rely on those orders [4]. The United States 
was at war with al-Qaeda, intelligence-gathering is inherent in war, 
and the Constitution appoints the president commander in chief.
But they had not been asked to give their own written assessments of 
the legality of domestic espionage. They based their answer in part 
on the attorney general's certification of the "form and legality" of 
the president's orders. Yet neither man had been allowed to see the 
program's codeword-classified legal analyses [5], which were prepared 
by John C. Yoo, Addington's close ally in the Justice Department's 
Office of Legal Counsel. Now they wanted to read Yoo's opinions for 
themselves [6].
"This is none of your business!" Addington exploded.
He was massive in his swivel chair, taut and still, potential energy 
amping up the menace. Addington's pugnacity was not an act. Nothing 
mattered more, as the vice president and his lawyer saw the world, 
than these new surveillance tools. Bush had made a decision. Debate 
could only blow the secret, slow down vital work, or call the 
president's constitutional prerogatives into question.
The NSA lawyers returned to their car empty-handed.

...

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/13/AR2008091302284.html

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to