September 25, 2008 4:00 AM PDT

Tech activist takes on governments over 'copyrighted' laws

By Declan McCullagh
News.com

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-10050687-38.html?tag=nl.e703


SEBASTOPOL, Calif.--From a corner of a nondescript office building at the 
edge of wine country, Carl Malamud is masterminding an electronic guerrilla 
war against governments across the nation.

Most geeks tend to be a bit obsessive, and Malamud is no exception. He's 
devoted his life to liberating laws, regulations, court cases, and the 
other myriad detritus that governments produce daily, but often lock up in 
proprietary databases or allow for-profit companies to sell for princely sums.

"One of the most important products our government makes is information," 
said the 49-year-old tech activist, who created a Lego animation to 
buttress his point. "We forget the important role of the government in 
producing these vast databases of information. That to me is infrastructure 
no different from electrical lines or roads."

Malamud's solution typically has been to create a proof-of-concept Web 
site, with the hopes of embarrassing government entities into building that 
infrastructure themselves. In the 1990s, his activism was responsible for 
persuading the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Patent and 
Trademark Office to make their data available for free on the Internet. 
Now, on his public.resource.org Web site, he's resumed posting hundreds of 
thousands of pages of government documents--all of which are, or at least 
should be, in the public domain.

This month, he's busy liberating California government codes, including San 
Francisco's building code, electrical code, fire code, and zoning code. 
That means purchasing printed copies for as little as $40 or as much as 
thousands of dollars, digitizing them, and posting them as PDF files 
without copy protection. Two months earlier, he posted the California 
Administrative Code.

One hitch is that San Francisco is one of those municipalities that claims 
its building code is copyrighted. (The notice says: "All rights reserved. 
No part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed by any means 
or stored in a database or retrieval system without prior written 
permission of the City and County of San Francisco.")

"I haven't heard from anybody" in the city government, Malamud said, since 
the documents were posted early last week. "That is a little surprising. I 
would have expected that someone would have at least called up and asked 
what we hoped to accomplish by doing this."

Adine Varah, a San Francisco deputy city attorney, declined to answer 
questions on Wednesday about legal action or the enforceability of the 
copyright notice. "The city and county of San Francisco strongly supports 
and ensures the public accessibility of its municipal codes," Varah said. 
"The San Francisco Municipal Code is a public record under our state and 
local public records laws. In addition, the city and county of San 
Francisco makes those codes publicly available for free on our Web site."

Varah warned that Malamud's document may prove to be out-of-date, and that 
city residents rely on it at their peril: "The city does not make any 
representation as to whether codes accessed on the Internet through 
non-city Web sites are accurate or up-to-date versions of the San Francisco 
Municipal Code."


California's Code of Regulations: only $3,288 for one year

One reason that city and state officials tend not to appreciate Malamud's 
efforts is that selling copies of regulations can be a source of revenue.

In California, Barclay's, a subsidiary of Thompson West, is the 
officially-designated publisher of the state Code of Regulations. A 2008 
price list says the complete code of regulations is $2,315 in printed form 
and $3,288 with a one-year subscription with updates. A CD-ROM version with 
updates is $1,556.

Susan Lapsley, director of California's office of administrative law, said 
on Wednesday that the state claims copyright "to protect that intellectual 
property of the state."

"Here in California, we are the ones who publish (and) compile the 
regulations," Lapsley said. To take legal action against Malamud, "we'd 
have to go through the state attorney general. We haven't investigated it."

Lapsley said the state already makes an effort to distribute at the 
materials on the Internet, in state depositories, and through libraries. 
She said having government-certified sources is useful because the code is 
constantly in flux, with her office approving or rejecting 5 to 10 
rulemakings a day and updating the official version accordingly. (In 
response, Malamud says that only a portion of the code is online and that 
the second part with building, electrical, plumbing, mechanical, and 
elevator regulations must be purchased.)

"It's a little bit more concrete in other states but here it's very 
organic, so the products they're getting from him are likely outdated," 
Lapsley said.

Sonoma County, just an hour's drive north of San Francisco, has chosen 
LexisNexis, part of Reed Elsevier, as its commercial publisher. The 
42-chapter Sonoma County Code can be bought from LexisNexis' online 
bookstore for a mere $200.

It's true that Sonoma's code, which covers everything from wood-burning 
stoves to abandoned vehicles and home water delivery, is available on 
LexisNexis' Web site without charge. But the company's terms of use says 
that the content is "protected by copyrights" and that it cannot be used 
for "commercial" purposes, one reading of which would prohibit commercial 
contractors from accessing it.

Malamud says that's why he prefers to buy physical copies and pay a local 
business to scan them in. "The electronic stuff either has a terms and 
conditions on checkout, or they're using some sort of copy-protected 
PDF--it is a DMCA thing," he said. "Plus, on checkout, you agree to abide 
by that. They'll put some sort of contractual restriction around it." The 
DMCA, or Digital Millennium Copyright Act, broadly restricts circumventing 
copy-protection measures.

At least California, San Francisco, and Sonoma let their citizens view the 
documents without using digital rights management techniques. Not New York 
state, which boasts a DRM-enabled building code on the Web site of the 
International Code Council. The PDF files can't be printed, probably 
because the ICC sells the code in book form for $105 a copy.

Given that Malamud has made a habit of butting heads with Reed Elsevier, 
Thompson West, and various government entities, it's almost surprising that 
he hasn't been sued. He's not exactly hoping for it, but also is doing 
nothing that could be interpreted as shying away from a fight. (The 
Electronic Frontier Foundation has from time to time provided him with 
legal advice. His nonprofit group, Public.Resource.Org, has received money 
from Google, eBay founder Pierre Omidyar's charitable foundation, and the 
Sunlight Foundation. He's renting office space from O'Reilly Media.)

One recent spat arose when the state of Oregon began sending 
cease-and-desist letters in April to Web sites that had posted the text of 
the Oregon Revised Statutes. That is "copyrighted material, the author and 
copyright owner of which is the Legislative Counsel Committee of the State 
of Oregon," the warning said.

Malamud and some of his allies replied by drafting a sample court 
complaint, which made the common-sense argument that the copyright was 
invalid: If citizens are required to comply with state law, they should be 
able to reproduce it freely without threat of lawsuits. And, besides, the 
government employees tasked with creating the law have their salaries paid 
for by taxpayers.

That dispute, at least, had a happy ending. Malamud showed up to testify 
before the state legislature ("the fact that works of government are in the 
public domain is thus one of the foundations of our system of government"), 
and politicians eventually backed down.

These are merely minor skirmishes in what amounts to a far broader 
ambition: to persuade all branches of government, at every level, including 
the court system, to open their massive data banks to free public access 
through the Internet. Malamud convened a group he calls the Independent 
Government Observers Task Force that has held a series of meetings and 
compiled a list of eight principles for what they view as a truly open 
government.

One of those says the data should be "reasonably structured to allow 
automated processing," which would allow Malamud and his allies--including 
the Internet Archive and the Boston Public Library, which 
Public.Resource.Org is paying to scan 2.5 million pages of congressional 
hearings--to repackage files with XML tags and permit them to be readily 
indexed and cataloged. Eventually, search engines might even become smart 
enough to interpret those tags and act accordingly.

"I believe access to knowledge is a human right," Malamud said. "When I see 
people putting barriers around useful information, I find that offensive."



=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to