Is Apple killing competition in its App Store?
Developers protest Apple nixing programs that might compete

By Suzanne Choney
MSNBC

8:09 a.m. CT, Thurs., Sept. 25, 2008

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26872181/


Apple's iron-fisted control of the iPhone is starting to draw protests from 
some software developers who wonder if the company's policy will end up 
squelching competition.

In at least one recent case, Apple appears to have denied approving a 
software program, Podcaster, for the iPhone, that could be considered 
competitive with the company's own offerings or plans.

Apple not only makes the iPhone, but also controls its operating system and 
has absolute authority over what programs can be added to the device.

While there are thousands of phones from which to choose, the iPhone's 
influence on the mobile market has been phenomenal in its short life. Its 
online App Store, which lets iPhone owners download software with a few 
clicks on the iPhone itself, has made its mobile platform extremely 
attractive to software developers.

After 15 months on the market, the iPhone is already the second top-selling 
smartphone in the United States, behind Research In Motion's Blackberry. 
Even with this week's introduction of Google's Android operating system for 
cell phones, one that is open to almost anyone who wants to create programs 
for it, it will take a lot to best the best in show.

Apple also controls more than 70 percent of the digital music player market 
in the country with its iPod, which is also part of the iPhone. Apple's 
online iTunes Store is also the leading digital music retailer in the 
nation, surpassing Wal-Mart earlier this year.

Podcaster lets iPhone users download Podcasts via the iPhone and eliminates 
the computer as an intermediary. Apple rejected the program for the App 
Store, part of the online iTunes Store, which delivers iPhone programs 
directly to the devices.

Duplication or competition?
Podcaster developer Alex Sokirynsky said he was told by Apple that 
Podcaster "duplicates the functionality" of the Podcast section of iTunes.

Another iPhone software developer, Fraser Speirs, said he believes there 
was another reason.

"Apple is now selecting for anti-competitive reasons," he wrote on his 
blog. "An application that I really, really want was rejected by Apple 
because it replaces a feature in Apple's own software."

Nokia, the world's largest phone maker, has practices similar to Apple in 
terms of top-to-bottom control, said Sravan Kundojjala, Strategy Analytics 
analyst on strategic technologies practice.

However, he said, Nokia "gives much more choice to developers. For example, 
it supports technologies that compete with its own. It supports Java, 
Flash, Silverlight in addition to its own Web Run-Time. This is not the 
case with Apple."

Apple's controls over the iPhone may be unique to the mobile phone 
industry, but it is not in others, said Michael Gartenberg, vice president 
of mobile strategy at Jupitermedia,

"For example, with video games, Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo control 
exactly what content goes on their devices," he said. "You can develop all 
you want, but if they don't publish the title, you can't get your content 
on their machines."

Avi Greengart, Current Analysis research director for mobile devices, said 
what Apple is doing in terms of control is "not unprecedented. Perhaps it's 
unprecedented in terms of scope, because Apple has this level of control 
over the entire process."

The App Store, launched in July, so far has more than 3,000 programs, 
ranging from games to finance. Some are free; others are for purchase.

No 'Pull My Finger'
Software developer Speirs also questions Apple's rejection of another 
program, "Pull My Finger," which features the sounds of flatulence, and was 
nixed because of its "limited utility to the broad iPhone and iPod touch 
user community," according to an e-mail the developer said he received from 
the company.

Even as silly as the program sounds, Speirs wrote that Apple's decision 
based on taste "is the first step to censoring for business advantage."

Apple did not respond to questions about this issue. Last March, when the 
company announced it would allow outside software developers to create 
programs for the iPhone, CEO Steve Jobs indicated Apple would have final 
say over those programs. He cited applications dealing with pornography, or 
those with inadequate security, as the kinds of programs that would be 
rejected.

Some of the company's actions since then indicate more restrictions may 
have been added.

There are still no voice-activated, turn-by-turn GPS programs that take 
advantage of the new iPhone's GPS chip, for example.

In July, Dominique Bonte of ABI Research wrote in her company's blog that 
navigation applications for the iPhone "have been held off by Apple up to 
now, presumably because they want to reap the profits of this killer 
application themselves."

A spokesman for one GPS software maker said the company wanted to pursue 
such a program, "even though there were some specific clauses in the 
developer agreement (with Apple) that said you can't write GPS navigation 
applications."

When questioned about that in July, an Apple spokesman declined to comment.

Competition, criteria concerns
Said Greengart: "In some cases, it sounds like Apple is rejecting 
applications because Apple itself intends to write these similar 
applications, and doesn't want there to be overlap."

However, he added, it's hard to know the real reasons because Apple says so 
little about what it is or isn't doing.

"The problem isn't that there are rules; the problem is that no one knows 
what the rules are, because Apple hasn't said what criteria it is using to 
reject applications," he said.

Gartenberg believes Apple is going through "a bit of a learning process" in 
working with iPhone software developers, as the company tries to understand 
"what works, what doesn't and how to effectively ensure the quality of 
applications," he said.

Software developer Speirs, whose "Exposure" program for the iPhone gives 
users access to all of Flickr's photo-sharing Web site, said Apple needs to 
"publish clear and unambiguous rules for what will be accepted and what 
will not," because developers are investing "time and resources" in their 
programs.

While there are issues, the App Store "is doing some incredible things" for 
mobile phone software programs, said Greengart. Among them, the store is 
"exposing consumers to the notion of downloading applications to their phones.

"From the consumer's standpoint, which is very important to a developer, 
the App Store is the one place to go to get applications. The browsing 
experience is superb, as is the buying experience. Basically, you click and 
a program is yours," he said.

And most software developers will "cope with Apple's control" because of 
the financial returns they might see, said Kundojjala of Strategy Analytics.

Still, with some developers speaking out, there is a crack in the wall. 
Until recently, it was unusual for software developers to publicly share 
their frustrations about the iPhone software program.

Most are hesitant to do so, worried about hurting their own chances of 
success with Apple, and keenly aware of the company's mania for secrecy and 
control.

"We're talking about an ecosystem that in a few months had 100 million 
downloads of applications," said Gartenberg. "Clearly, Apple is doing more 
right than wrong."

URL: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26872181/


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to