September 26, 2008, 9:45 am

The $10 Million Light Bulb
By Eric A. Taub
NY Times



In these trying economic times, who couldn't use an extra $10 million?

If you're good with lighting, you might want to try and win the L Prize, 
the Department of Energy's competition to create a new generation of light 
bulbs.

The money (it could be less depending on financing) will go to the company 
that creates a viable solid-state LED replacement for the standard 60-watt 
incandescent bulb (a second prize will be awarded for a replacement for a 
PAR 38 halogen reflector lamp).

Announced last May, the contest holds winners to rigorous criteria. In the 
the case of the standard bulb, it must produce light equivalent to 60 watts 
but use less than 10 watts and last longer than 25,000 hours (with four 
hours a day of use, that's equivalent to more than 17 years), among other 
requirements. The halogen replacement will need to create the equivalent of 
60 watts of light but use less than 11 watts.

If LED lighting eventually takes off, this could be a big deal. According 
to the Department of Energy, if every socket in the United States that now 
had a 60-watt bulb switched to an LED equivalent, the country would save 34 
terawatt-hours of electricity a year, or enough to light Las Vegas for two 
years (no jokes about whether it might be better to keep it dark).

While not a requirement, the guidelines also call for the standard bulb 
replacement to cost no more than $8 by the third year that it's on the market.

The winning product will be heavily promoted by various utilities around 
the country, might be included in TV ads and will automatically qualify for 
Energy Star status. The winning company has to make at least 250,000 units 
the first year, and the production of the LED chip must occur in the United 
States, according to a speaker at a Department of Energy Webinar Tuesday.

Through October, New Yorkers can get a sense of LED lighting at the Museum 
of Modern Art's Cellophane House, a 2,000-square-foot prototype home now on 
display at the museum as part of the exhibition, "Home Delivery: 
Fabricating the Modern Dwelling." Using only Philips LED lamps and fixtures 
for illumination, energy savings average 25 percent, but would have been 
higher if the lighting designers did not decide to illuminate the roof with 
colored LED lamps.

LED replacement bulbs currently exist, but at around $80-100 each, they're 
not likely to be on the shopping list of most consumers this Christmas. For 
the last few weeks, I've been testing two: one is the equivalent of a PAR 
30 60-watt halogen reflector lamp (the kind of lamp you see in recessed 
ceilings that is used to project light downwards) and the other is an LED 
version of a standard 40-watt light bulb.

The reflector uses 6 watts and its light output does the job, shining down 
on a kitchen counter and creating for all intents and purposes, just about 
the same color as its neighboring standard halogen version. No one who's 
looked at the light output can tell the difference.

The incandescent bulb replacement still needs some work. The 40-watt 
equivalent uses just 4 watts, and is said to last 50,000 hours or 35 years 
(I'm putting this bulb in my will). But the color of the light, while 
described as "warm," is still whiter than a standard bulb.

Right now, one of the big problems in the nascent LED business is quality. 
Simply put, there's a lot of junk out there, apparent even to an amateur 
taking a casual look at the construction of some of these units. The L 
Prize will also set manufacturing standards, which should weed out the 
stuff that would otherwise give the technology a bad name. As one Webinar 
speaker said Tuesday, "When it comes to LED lighting, quality is key."


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to