OCTOBER 1, 2008

Satellite-Surveillance Program to Begin Despite Privacy Concerns

By SIOBHAN GORMAN
Wall Street Journal

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122282336428992785.html?mod=googlenews_wsj


WASHINGTON -- The Department of Homeland Security will proceed with the 
first phase of a controversial satellite-surveillance program, even 
though an independent review found the department hasn't yet ensured the 
program will comply with privacy laws.

Congress provided partial funding for the program in a little-debated 
$634 billion spending measure that will fund the government until early 
March. For the past year, the Bush administration had been fighting 
Democratic lawmakers over the spy program, known as the National 
Applications Office.

The program is designed to provide federal, state and local officials 
with extensive access to spy-satellite imagery -- but no eavesdropping 
-- to assist with emergency response and other domestic-security needs, 
such as identifying where ports or border areas are vulnerable to terrorism.

Since the department proposed the program a year ago, several Democratic 
lawmakers have said that turning the spy lens on America could violate 
Americans' privacy and civil liberties unless adequate safeguards were 
required.

A new 60-page Government Accountability Office report said the 
department "lacks assurance that NAO operations will comply with 
applicable laws and privacy and civil liberties standards," according to 
a person familiar with the document. The report, which is unclassified 
but considered sensitive, hasn't been publicly released, but was 
described and quoted by several people who have read it.

The report cites gaps in privacy safeguards. The department, it found, 
lacks controls to prevent improper use of domestic-intelligence data by 
other agencies and provided insufficient assurance that requests for 
classified information will be fully reviewed to ensure it can be 
legally provided.

A senior homeland-security official took issue with the GAO's broad 
conclusion, saying the department has worked hard to include many layers 
of privacy protection. Program activities have "an unprecedented amount 
of legal review," he said, adding that the GAO is seeking a level of 
proof that can't be demonstrated until the program is launched.

Homeland Security spokeswoman Laura Keehner said department officials 
concluded that the program "complies with all existing laws" because the 
GAO report didn't say the program doesn't.

Addressing the gaps the agency cited, Ms. Keehner said current laws 
already govern the use of intelligence data and the department has an 
additional procedure to monitor its use. The department will also work 
with other intelligence agencies to "ensure that legal reviews and 
protection of classified information will be effective," she said.

In response to the GAO report, House Homeland Security Committee 
Chairman Bennie G. Thompson of Mississippi and other Democrats asked 
Congress to freeze the money for the program until after the November 
election so the next administration could examine it.

But the bill Congress approved, which President George W. Bush signed 
into law Tuesday, allows the department to launch a limited version, 
focused only on emergency response and scientific needs. The department 
must meet additional requirements before it can expand operations to 
include homeland-security and law-enforcement surveillance.

The restrictions were "the most we could have required without a 
complete prohibition," said Darek Newby, an aide to Democratic Rep. 
David Price of North Carolina, who heads the House homeland-security 
spending panel.

But California Rep. Jane Harman, who heads a homeland-security 
subcommittee on intelligence, said that even limited funding allows the 
department to launch the program, providing a platform to expand its 
surveillance whether or not privacy requirements are met.

"Having learned my lesson" with the National Security Agency's 
warrantless-surveillance program, she said, "I don't want to go there 
again unless and until the legal framework for the entire program is 
entirely spelled out."

Rep. Thompson vowed to fight expansion of the program until privacy 
issues are further addressed.

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to