Studies Lift Hopes for Great Lakes Wind Turbine Farms

By Kari Lydersen
Washington Post Staff Writer

Tuesday, October 7, 2008; A09

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/10/06/AR2008100602574_pf.html


CHICAGO -- Picture 100,000 wind turbines rising from the Great Lakes off 
Michigan's shores, casting spinning shadows on the water and producing 
electricity for the entire Upper Midwest.

This surreal image is conjured by a study released last Tuesday by the 
Michigan State University Land Policy Institute. It analyzed wind 
potential in the Great Lakes and found that 100,000 turbines off 
Michigan's coasts could produce 321,000 megawatts of energy.

That scenario, however, is highly unlikely because of the cost and 
environmental and other considerations. But wind power advocates hope it 
is a starting point for development of the world's first freshwater, 
offshore wind farms -- in the Great Lakes.

Although Michigan borders four Great Lakes and has the most offshore 
wind potential, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, is likely to beat it to the punch 
with a proposed wind farm in Lake Erie several miles from Cleveland.

Last week a task force chaired by the Cuyahoga County prosecutor 
released an installment in an ongoing $1 million feasibility study 
giving the project a green light on geologic and wind-potential grounds. 
If the study continues to yield positive findings, construction of two 
to 10 wind turbines and a research station could start in about two years.

"We believe we are in a race to be first in the Great Lakes, and by 
doing so, the pilot project will blaze a trail for economic 
opportunities for the area," said Ryan Miday, spokesman for the task 
force. "This is about making this area a hub for wind energy that brings 
in other supply-chain component manufacturers. It's a vision of creating 
a new industry in this area centered around wind."

Meanwhile, Wisconsin is exploring three offshore wind projects, with 
public comment periods in progress, according to the state Public 
Service Commission.

Offshore wind projects have been developed in European countries such as 
Germany, Denmark and Great Britain.

Although U.S. projects are in development in the Gulf of Mexico and the 
Atlantic, none are operating. The proposed 130-turbine Cape Wind project 
in Nantucket Sound has drawn heated opposition from residents who say it 
will mar views and harm birds.

The proposed Great Lakes offshore wind projects have not drawn 
significant opposition, although even proponents acknowledge they could 
affect views, lake ecology and recreation.

The Ohio project proposes sinking foundations for 260-foot-tall wind 
turbines into bedrock and laying electrical cable below the Great Lakes 
floor. The construction could have ramifications for fish breeding and 
lake-floor ecology in general, including the effects of 
electromagnetism, noise and vibrations. But the Ohio study says that in 
Europe, wind turbine foundations on the sea floor have become habitats 
for fish.

"Anytime you're trying to put something in the water, it raises a whole 
host of questions that I don't think any state has adequately examined," 
said Joel Brammeier, vice president for policy at the Alliance for the 
Great Lakes. "We're certainly not at the point we should be permitting 
projects. We're at the point those questions should be asked in a public 
forum and responded to -- everything from aesthetics to actual impacts 
on the bottom and fish habitat. What we don't want is the Cape Wind of 
the Midwest."

The production estimate of 321,000 megawatts cited in the Michigan State 
study includes turbines at all depths. Existing offshore wind turbines 
are in water 197 feet deep or less. At that depth, the study says, 
103,000 megawatts could be generated with 33,861 turbines. Concerns 
about environmental impacts and opposition from residents would 
significantly reduce that potential. But, said study co-author Soji 
Adelaja, that still means a lot of potential wind power.

"Just announcing potential doesn't really mean anything, but hopefully 
this will start deliberations about how to do it," he said. "Michigan 
has these old abandoned industrial facilities used for automobile parts. 
If wind energy picks up, those could be redirected to making wind 
components."

The state has not actively pursued offshore wind energy but expects it 
may get proposals from private firms, said John Sarver, supervisor of 
technical assistance in the Michigan Energy Office and chairman of the 
Michigan Wind Working Group. Such proposals would go primarily through 
the Department of Environmental Quality.

"Tomorrow someone could knock on the DEQ's door and say they want to do 
something, and of course the state will have to respond," Sarver said. 
"Or another possibility is down the road sometime the state would issue 
a request for proposal. We haven't had a chance to look over all the 
issues yet, so it would be a learning curve for everybody."

The areas in Michigan most conducive to offshore turbines might be the 
state's northeast coast in Lake Huron and the coasts of the Upper 
Peninsula, because they are relatively unpopulated, Adelaja said. But 
wind farms should ideally be located near the market for energy.

Tom Alisankus, chairman of a committee studying a proposed land-based 
wind farm in central Wisconsin, said offshore projects are far more 
palatable to people like him who have negative views of land-based wind 
power.

"Those have a lot more efficacy than land-based projects as far as 
actually generating energy and not interfering with people's lives," he 
said. "But people have to remember this is not free energy; there's a 
ton of expense in making these things, and they still have a huge carbon 
footprint in the manufacturing."

While not endorsing offshore wind, Brammeier of the Alliance for the 
Great Lakes said its negative impacts must be balanced against the 
long-term environmental benefits of clean energy.

"The states who own the lake bottom are empowered and required to secure 
it for the public interest," he said. "When you're talking about 
something like a pipeline through the lakes that binds us to a 
19th-century way of thinking about energy, versus the development of 
wind resources, which is completely forward-looking, you're certainly 
looking at a different measure of whether that's serving the public 
interest."

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to