November 13, 2008

3 Flat-Screen Makers Plead Guilty to Trying to Keep Prices High
By STEVE LOHR
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/13/technology/13panel.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


Prices for the flat screens in televisions, personal computers and 
cellphones have plummeted in recent years — but the decline would have 
been even faster if it hadn’t been for an international price-fixing 
cartel, the Justice Department said on Wednesday.

Three leading flat-screen producers — LG Display of South Korea, Sharp 
of Japan and Chunghwa Picture Tubes of Taiwan — pleaded guilty and 
agreed to pay a total of $585 million in criminal fines for their role 
in fixing the price of liquid-crystal display panels.

LG is paying the most: a $400 million fine, the second-highest criminal 
fine ever imposed by the Justice Department’s antitrust division. The 
largest was the $500 million paid in 1999 by F. Hoffmann-La Roche, a 
Swiss pharmaceutical giant, for leading a price-fixing cartel in vitamin 
supplements.

The settlement, legal experts say, is unlikely to be the end of the 
flat-panel case. Under the settlement, the three companies have agreed 
to cooperate with the Justice Department’s continuing investigation. 
Thomas O. Barnett, assistant attorney general in charge of the 
department’s antitrust division, pointed out at a news conference on 
Wednesday that the American investigation involved the coordinated 
efforts of enforcement officials in Europe and Asia, as well as the 
United States.

Government investigations, legal specialists said, are under way in 
Europe, Japan and South Korea. In the United States, private 
class-action suits have already been filed seeking damages for companies 
that purchased flat-panel screens, and for consumers who bought 
flat-panel-equipped products. Some of the private suits, if successful, 
could provide a way for consumers to benefit, though the compensation 
for any individual would probably be slight.

The Justice Department, in a statement, noted that the price-fixing 
conspiracy affected screens sold to American companies, and cited three 
by name: Dell, Apple and Motorola. Those companies, and others, could 
have the basis for private suits.

The LCD business is a $100-billion-a-year market and growing, but prices 
are falling relentlessly. Recently, panel prices have often been cut in 
half each year, a downward trajectory even steeper than in other 
technology markets known for steady price pressure, like those for 
computer chips and hard drives.

In the last six months alone, the price of a 15.4-inch panel for a 
notebook PC has dropped to $63, from $97, and a 32-inch LCD for a 
television has gone to $223, from $321, according to iSuppli, a market 
research firm.

The price-fixing conspiracy, industry analysts said, was an effort to 
slow the speed of price declines. “These companies were trying to get a 
toehold to protect profits in a very difficult market,” said Richard 
Doherty, director of research at Envisioneering, a technology consulting 
firm.

Without the price-fixing scheme, liquid-crystal panels would have been 
even cheaper, and they are important parts in a wide range of products. 
For example, the screen represents 10 to 20 percent of the total cost of 
a notebook PC, said Rob Enderle, an independent analyst in San Jose, Calif.

The effect was somewhat higher prices. “These price-fixing conspiracies 
affected millions of American consumers who use computers, cellphones 
and numerous other household electronics every day,” Mr. Barnett said in 
a statement.

The settlement, legal specialists say, does not precisely indicate the 
extent of the consumer harm. Under antitrust law, a company can be fined 
up to twice the gain it derived from its misconduct.

But in a settlement, the fine amounts could represent negotiated levels, 
or less than the total harm to consumers, said C. Scott Hemphill, an 
antitrust expert at the Columbia University law school.

“And this settlement only deals with the harm in the United States,” he 
said. “The global totals may be many times larger.”

During the Bush administration, antitrust enforcement has been selective 
and often guided by a hands-off, pro-business philosophy, legal experts 
say. But price-fixing cartels are an area of antitrust in which there is 
no debate about enforcement. In a 2004 Supreme Court decision, which was 
unanimous, cartels were called “the supreme evil of antitrust.”

“Cartels are regarded as the most dangerous form of anticompetitive 
conduct,” said Andrew I. Gavil, a law professor at Howard University. 
“The reason is that the potential impact on consumers is so great, and 
there is no plausible justification for it.”

With the settlement, Mr. Barnett, who will leave the Justice Department 
next week, has provided “an answer to critics who doubted he would take 
on big cases of this kind,” Mr. Gavil said.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to