Editorial

The Ethics of the Rabbis

Forward
Thu. Nov 13, 2008

On the surface, the crisis besetting America's largest kosher 
meatpacker looks a lot like the larger infection that is crippling 
the nation's economy and undoing so many iconic brands, from Lehman 
Brothers to AIG to Circuit City. Like other firms, Agriprocessors 
fell victim to the arrogance of its owners and the dereliction of 
outside regulators. Like others, the crippling of Agriprocessors hits 
hard in thousands of households where daily life was dependent on the 
smooth operations of a trusted company.

Unlike the others, however, Agriprocessors' downfall is not simply an 
economic crisis, but also a spiritual and moral one. Kosher food is 
not meant to be a mere foodstuff, but rather a vehicle for bringing 
sanctity into one of the most basic activities of daily life. Those 
who choose to live by that discipline rely on kosher certification to 
guarantee that the food they eat has been produced in a manner worthy 
of its spiritual mission. The behavior attributed to Agriprocessors 
and its owners - abusing employees, illegally hiring and endangering 
children, befouling the environment, overlooking sanitation rules - 
ought to disqualify the company's products from receiving religious 
certification by any standard worthy of the name. That the products 
continue to be accepted as kosher, even as the company's owners face 
massive fines and jail time on suspicion of misdeeds that have 
shocked a nation, is a scandal nearly as great as the owners' actions 
themselves.

Ever since the Forward published its first reports two years ago on 
working conditions at the Agriprocessors slaughterhouse in Postville, 
Iowa, Orthodox rabbinic authorities have insisted that the violations 
attributed to the company are not directly related to the rules of 
kosher slaughter, and therefore are outside the certifying rabbis' 
jurisdiction. Kosher certification, they have explained, follows 
time-honored biblical and talmudic principles that cannot be altered 
by modern rabbinic fiat. Many have derided and even ridiculed the 
Conservative rabbinate for seeking to develop a new form of 
certification, Hekhsher Tzedek, that would consider a company's 
ethical behavior alongside its slaughtering techniques.

Besides, Orthodox rabbis told us, protecting workers and safeguarding 
the environment are the job of government, not the clergy. If the 
government with all its lawyers has not acted against the Postville 
plant, why should rabbis presume to?

...


http://www.forward.com/articles/14561/


***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to