Law professor fires back at song-swapping lawsuits

Nov 16, 2008  2:37 PM (ET)

By RODRIQUE NGOWI
Associated Press

http://apnews.myway.com//article/20081116/D94G7EMG0.html


BOSTON (AP) - The music industry's courtroom campaign against people who 
share songs online is coming under counterattack.

A Harvard Law School professor has launched a constitutional assault 
against a federal copyright law at the heart of the industry's 
aggressive strategy, which has wrung payments from thousands of 
song-swappers since 2003.

The professor, Charles Nesson, has come to the defense of a Boston 
University graduate student targeted in one of the music industry's 
lawsuits. By taking on the case, Nesson hopes to challenge the basis for 
the suit, and all others like it.

Nesson argues that the Digital Theft Deterrence and Copyright Damages 
Improvement Act of 1999 is unconstitutional because it effectively lets 
a private group - the Recording Industry Association of America, or RIAA 
- carry out civil enforcement of a criminal law. He also says the music 
industry group abused the legal process by brandishing the prospects of 
lengthy and costly lawsuits in an effort to intimidate people into 
settling cases out of court.

Nesson, the founder of Harvard's Berkman Center for Internet and 
Society, said in an interview that his goal is to "turn the courts away 
from allowing themselves to be used like a low-grade collection agency."

Nesson is best known for defending the man who leaked the Pentagon 
Papers and for consulting on the case against chemical companies that 
was depicted in the film "A Civil Action." His challenge against the 
music labels, made in U.S. District Court in Boston, is one of the most 
determined attempts to derail the industry's flurry of litigation.

The initiative has generated more than 30,000 complaints against people 
accused of sharing songs online. Only one case has gone to trial; nearly 
everyone else settled out of court to avoid damages and limit the 
attorney fees and legal costs that escalate over time.

Nesson intervened after a federal judge in Boston asked his office to 
represent Joel Tenenbaum, who was among dozens of people who appeared in 
court in RIAA cases without legal help.

The 24-year-old Tenenbaum is a graduate student accused by the RIAA of 
downloading at least seven songs and making 816 music files available 
for distribution on the Kazaa file-sharing network in 2004. He offered 
to settle the case for $500, but music companies rejected that, 
demanding $12,000.

The Digital Theft Deterrence Act, the law at issue in the case, sets 
damages of $750 to $30,000 for each infringement, and as much as 
$150,000 for a willful violation. That means Tenenbaum could be forced 
to pay $1 million if it is determined that his alleged actions were willful.

The music industry group isn't conceding any ground to Nesson and 
Tenenbaum. The RIAA has said in court documents that its efforts to 
enforce the copyright law is protected under the First Amendment right 
to petition the courts for redress of grievances. Tenenbaum also failed, 
the music group noted, to notify the U.S. Attorney General that that he 
wanted to contest the law's constitutional status.

Cara Duckworth, a spokeswoman for the RIAA, said her group's pursuit of 
people suspected of music piracy is a fair response to the industry's 
multibillion-dollar losses since peer-to-peer networks began making it 
easy for people to share massive numbers of songs online.

"What should be clear is that illegally downloading and distributing 
music comes with many risks and is not an anonymous activity," Duckworth 
said.

Still, wider questions persist on whether the underlying copyright law 
is constitutional, said Ray Beckerman, a Forest Hills, N.Y.-based 
attorney who has represented other downloading defendants and runs a 
blog tracking the most prominent cases.

One federal judge has held that the constitutional question is "a 
serious argument," Beckerman said. "There are two law review articles 
that have said that it is unconstitutional, and there are three cases 
that said that it might be unconstitutional."

In September, a federal judge granted a new trial to a Minnesota woman 
who had been ordered to pay $220,000 for pirating 24 songs. In that 
ruling, U.S. District Judge Michael J. Davis called on Congress to 
change copyright laws to prevent excessive awards in similar cases. He 
wrote that he didn't discount the industry's claim that illegal 
downloading has hurt the recording business, but called the award 
"wholly disproportionate" to the industry's losses.

In the Boston case, Nesson is due to meet attorneys for the music 
industry for a pretrial conference on Tuesday, ahead of a trial set for 
Dec. 1.

Entertainment attorney Jay Cooper, who specializes in music and 
copyright issues at Los Angeles-based Greenberg Traurig, is convinced 
that Nesson will not persuade the federal court to strike down the 
copyright law. He said the statutory damages it awards enable recording 
companies to get compensation in cases where it is difficult to prove 
actual damages.

The record companies have echoed that line of defense. In court filings 
in Tenenbaum's case, they contend that the damages allowed by the law 
are "intended not only to compensate the copyright owner, but also to 
punish the infringer (and) deter other potential infringers."

But are these lawsuits the only way the record industry could deter 
piracy? Nesson believes the industry could develop new ways to prevent 
copyright material from being shared illegally. One idea would be to 
bundle music with ads and post it for free online, he says.

"There are alternative ways," he said, "of packaging entertainment to 
return revenue to artists."

---

On the Net:

Harvard's Berkman Center for Internet and Society: 
http://cyber.law.harvard.edu

Ray Beckerman's blog: http://recordingindustryvspeople.blogspot.com

The Recording Industry Association of America on music piracy: 
http://www.riaa.com/physicalpiracy.php

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to