Can concept of clean coal be salvaged?
Study looks at method that drastically improves efficiency, cuts emissions

By Bryn Nelson
MSNBC Columnist

updated 7:28 a.m. CT, Mon., Nov. 17, 2008

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/27685081/


Coal may be a four-letter word for former Vice President Al Gore and 
many environmentalists. But some researchers believe technology may yet 
salvage the concept of “clean coal” — or at least cleaner coal — as an 
alternative to foreign oil while the drive for longer-term alternative 
energy picks up steam.

Among the latest scientists to weigh in, researchers at the University 
of Padova in Italy have led detailed simulations concluding that a new 
process for transforming coal into gas could improve on the efficiency 
of conventional coal-to-gas, or gasification, techniques by 28 percent 
and release 22 percent less carbon dioxide — the main gas linked to 
global warming. Coupling the scheme to a coal-to-liquid process, the 
authors conclude, could yield 40 percent more synthetic fuel, release 32 
percent less carbon dioxide and contribute to a 70 percent rise in 
overall energy efficiency.

The study, being published in the Nov. 19 issue of the journal Energy & 
Fuels, carries several big caveats, including an estimated price tag 
that may be hard for power companies to swallow. And many environmental 
organizations have dismissed the notion that coal could ever be 
extracted and burned in an earth-friendly way as little more than 
“greenwashing.”

But as part of his campaign platform, President-elect Barack Obama has 
pledged to enter into public-private partnerships to develop five 
“first-of-a-kind” commercial scale coal-fired plants with clean carbon 
capture and sequestration technology.

Coal-producing states such as Pennsylvania and Montana also have 
proposed building coal-to-liquid plants, in part to relieve dependence 
on foreign oil.

And with some studies suggesting the U.S. boasts an abundant (though 
non-renewable) supply, a host of new modifications are being proposed 
for cleaning up the pollution-spewing source of nearly half of all 
electricity produced in the country.

Economically feasible?
With its assertion that coal is “the only reasonable large-scale 
conventional source left in the medium term,” the new Italian study 
argues that “the urgent need of exploiting coal to produce both electric 
power and liquid fuels is a strong motivation to study how to improve 
the related production processes.”

Alberto Bertucco, a professor of chemical engineering at the University 
of Padova and a study co-author, said the big question is whether the 
concept will be economically feasible for a full-size plant producing 
syngas, a mixture of hydrogen and carbon monoxide gas.

“If the idea is good technically, probably it’s worthwhile to see if it 
could be applied at this scale. You get rid of the need for Saudi 
Arabia,” he said. “But this process must be sustained to get plants 
which are viable in the sense that they don’t cost too much.”

Traditional coal combustion produces steam capable of turning 
electricity-generating turbines. As coal’s carbon content oxidizes, 
however, the process also yields the potent pollutants sulfur dioxide 
and nitrogen oxide, as well as the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide.

A somewhat less polluting alternative, a process known as integrated 
gasification combined cycle (IGCC), produces syngas to power a turbine 
generator. Another possibility is to use that syngas mix to produce 
heavier hydrocarbons in the form of liquid synthetic fuels.

For the gasification reactions, burning coal typically requires pure 
oxygen, Bertucco said. “So there is a part of the plant that is to get 
pure oxygen to be fed to the gasifier. This part is expensive and 
energy-demanding.”

In collaboration with the global engineering and construction contractor 
Foster Wheeler and an independent consultant, Bertucco and post-doctoral 
fellow Maria Sudiro proposed burning the needed coal with cheaper air 
instead of oxygen.

Last month, Foster Wheeler won the right to perform a feasibility study 
for a coal-to-liquid (CTL) plant in China spearheaded by South Africa’s 
Sasol Synfuels International, owner of the only currently operational 
CTL plant.

The new study, akin to a how-to guide, explains how the necessary 
separation of the combustion and gasification processes could be safely 
achieved. “In the combustor, we burn roughly one-fourth of the coal, and 
we do this with air,” Bertucco said.

But the process needs something to transport the generated heat to the 
gasifier. The solution, he said, is heat-conducting sand.

“Coal plus steam makes carbon monoxide plus hydrogen, but a lot of 
energy is needed and this is relieved by the sand,” he said. “This is 
circulated continuously from one reaction to another, back and forth.”

The process requires abundant caution to avoid the risk of an explosion, 
though Bertucco said the danger can be overcome by properly controlling 
the pressure in different parts of the plant to prevent air from coming 
into contact with the gasifier.

Weaning U.S. from fossil fuels
Although the idea of using sand to aid coal gasification isn’t 
necessarily revolutionary, Bertucco said the engineering study was the 
first to attach reliable efficiency and emission numbers to the process 
of separating combustion from gasification.

As for the economics of outfitting new plants to use air and sand, he 
conceded the upfront costs would be “quite high” until the first 
facilities come online. As a rough estimate, he said the CTL process, 
including capital and operational costs, would require between $30 and 
$50 to produce the equivalent of one barrel of oil.

Coal-to-liquid processing has been around since German chemists invented 
the Fischer-Tropsch technique to convert coal-based syngas into liquid 
fuel in the 1920s to supply the coal-rich but petroleum-poor nation with 
fuel for its military.

But in the last half-century, only South Africa’s Sasol petrochemical 
company has used the chemical process for full-scale synthetic fuel 
production. Only a handful of plants in the U.S. even use the initial 
reaction in that process, the coal-to-gas IGCC technique, though more 
are expected to come online in the next few years.

The same general principles also could be used for transforming biomass 
to syngas, though Bertucco said the process is more complicated than 
coal gasification.

Many environmentalists still consider the notion of “clean coal” — no 
matter what the technological advances — anathema to weaning the U.S. 
from fossil fuels.

In a Nov. 9 New York Times editorial, Gore argued that “those who spend 
hundreds of millions promoting ‘clean coal’ technology consistently omit 
the fact that there is little investment and not a single large-scale 
demonstration project in the United States for capturing and safely 
burying all of this pollution. If the coal industry can make good on 
this promise, then I’m all for it. But until that day comes, we simply 
cannot any longer base the strategy for human survival on a cynical and 
self-interested illusion.”

Vaclav Smil, an energy policy expert at Canada's University of Manitoba 
, dismissed the Italian study’s premise outright, writing in an e-mail, 
“There are literally hundreds of such ‘breakthroughs’ every month in 
energy conversion literature, theoretical or tiny pilot plant studies 
that eventually amount to nothing or to marginal gains not worth 
pursuing compared to the real root of the problem,” which he 
characterized as excessive energy consumption by the U.S.

At a Nov. 10 Seattle screening of the new pro-biodiesel documentary 
“FUEL,” however, Rep. Jay Inslee (D-Wash.) said he believed “clean coal” 
intended for electricity production could be viable if paired with 
carbon capture and sequestration.

Federal money for research and development could be directed toward 
improving the carbon sequestration technology, he said, as long as it 
was made clear to coal companies that the funding wouldn’t come at the 
expense of a push toward alternative energy. As for coal-to-liquid 
technology, Inslee said, “I think that is highly unlikely to be successful.”

Need for government support
Nevertheless, Los Angeles-based Rentech Inc. has developed its own 
version of the Fischer-Tropsch process to convert coal to liquid fuel.

Earlier this year, the company’s demonstration facility in Commerce 
City, Colo., became the only operational synthetic transportation fuels 
facility in the country, producing about 10 barrels per day of 
transportation fuels such as jet fuel and diesel.

Harold Wright, chief technology officer for Rentech, said the method of 
improving the efficiency of synthetic gas and fuel production outlined 
by Bertucco’s group seems reasonable. Anything that can be done to lower 
the considerable expense associated with separating oxygen from air for 
coal combustion, he said, would be “very positive.” But a full-scale 
facility operating under those principles, Wright said, would likely 
require government support.

Large coal-based research projects in the U.S., such as a 275-megawatt 
IGCC plant in Illinois that would have demonstrated advanced coal 
gasification and carbon capture and sequestration, already have 
foundered over budgetary concerns.

Officials at the Department of Energy’s FutureGen Program dramatically 
scaled back plans for the plant earlier this year when the cost was 
revised dramatically upward, from $950 million to $1.6 billion, due 
largely to an increase in the cost of construction.

A scaled-back FutureGen project, according to Office of Fossil Energy 
spokesman John Grasser, will consist of a commercial coal plant venture 
paired with a carbon capture demonstration.

Under the cooperative agreement with the coal industry, the commercial 
sector would build a power plant while the project would contribute 
money toward carbon capture technology.

In the meantime, smaller companies are charging ahead with their own 
technology. Bismarck, N.D.-based Basin Electric Power Cooperative 
operates a coal-gasification plant near Beulah, N.D., that captures more 
carbon dioxide than any other site in the world, sending 9,000 tons of 
the gas by pipeline to Saskatchewan, Canada, to be used for enhancing 
underground oil recovery.

The geological question of whether sequestration can be a permanent 
solution remains unanswered, though Rep. Inslee pointed to companies 
such as Bellevue, Wash.-based Ramgen Power Systems, which is using 
supersonic air and gas compressors more commonly associated with 
aircraft technology to compress, capture and sequester carbon dioxide.

“No utility is going to sequester carbon dioxide if it’s significantly 
more expensive than current technology,” Grasser said. “The goal is to 
produce the electricity coming from a coal gasification facility with 
carbon capture and to get the cost down so that it’s no more than 10 
percent above a similar process where you don’t capture the carbon dioxide.”

In the end, the question of whether “clean coal” technology can begin to 
approach viability as a greener energy solution is likely to boil down 
to a fundamental matter of economics.

URL: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/27685081/

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to