November 18, 2008

Training a Gimlet Eye on the News Media and Finding Them Wanting
By BRIAN STELTER
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/18/arts/television/18medi.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


As self-absorbed as the news media can sometimes be, only a small amount of 
self-criticism appears on television.

The cable news networks seldom speak about their infatuation with stories 
of white women gone missing or delve into their military analysts’ 
conflicts of interest. But a new series on the Independent Film Channel, 
“The IFC Media Project,” finds plenty to be introspective about.

The program, which begins on Tuesday, calls itself a “user’s guide to how 
the news gets made.” It examines a wide range of subjects, from coverage of 
the financial crisis to the narrative of the “war on drugs.”

“The point of the show is that American journalism and especially broadcast 
journalism right now seems to be spiraling downward,” said Gideon Yago, the 
host of the six half-hour installments.

Mr. Yago, 29, may seem too young to be disillusioned about journalism, but 
his seven years spent at MTV News and his contributions to CBS News would 
suggest otherwise. In an interview last week, he said he had watched “news 
stories that were super-relevant get the kibosh because Purina had bought 
the first hour of the morning show and they wanted to do a profile on fat 
cats.” He added, though, that the practices examined on the program are not 
only ones he has witnessed personally.

Asked if he has become a journalistic cynic, he responded, “That, my 
friend, is the understatement of the year.” He then quoted a line from the 
1987 film “Broadcast News”: “You’re lucky if you can get out while you 
could still cry.“

“The IFC Media Project” gives Mr. Yago a chance to critique what he sees as 
misleading media practices. Much of the territory it covers is well worn in 
print and on the Internet, although not addressed as often on television. 
Mr. Yago said the series hoped to cover both original stories and ones that 
“fell through the cracks on broadcast.”

The first segment profiles Larry Garrison, a consultant who helps families 
of missing children deal with the news media. At the time of the filming 
Mr. Garrison was a spokesman for the family of Caylee Anthony, the Florida 
toddler who was reported missing last July.

“People love to hear stories about tragedies,” Mr. Garrison tells the 
producers, sitting in his office, a framed copy of a People magazine cover 
saying “What Happened to Caylee?” on the wall. “It’s like eating a potato 
chip; you just can’t stop.”

Cable channels presented almost 900 reports about Caylee in the first 12 
weeks after she disappeared. “During that time, approximately 100,000 other 
children were reported missing,” the program observes. (Last week The 
Orlando Sentinel reported that Mr. Garrison had collected payments from 
news organizations. He denies profiting from the Anthonys, although he is 
no longer working with them.)

But the segment does not directly ask the producers of cable news about why 
they devote so much time to certain cases. Similarly, the second episode’s 
long examination of television military analysts, titled “How to Sell a 
War,” does not include the perspective of the networks that hired the 
analysts and allowed them to espouse the government’s talking points 
without any disclosures about their ties to the Pentagon or to defense 
contractors. The segment is based on an investigation by The New York Times 
in April and includes an interview with the Times reporter David Barstow.

Meghan O’Hara, the program’s creator and executive producer, said the 
omission was not for lack of trying. “None of them wanted to talk to us,” 
she said.

The television networks have generally declined to talk about the military 
analysts. On Monday representatives of ABC, NBC and CBS declined comment.

Ms. O’Hara worked with the filmmaker Michael Moore on the documentaries 
“Bowling for Columbine,” “Fahrenheit 9/11” and “Sicko,” and the series 
adopts an outraged tone reminiscent of those left-leaning films.

Jennifer Caserta, the general manager of the Independent Film Channel, 
sidestepped questions about whether the program represents any kind of 
partisanship. “The goal was to just present the stories and allow the 
audience to make the judgment,” she said.

While the series is essentially an exercise in media literacy, it is far 
less academic than one might expect. Each episode includes an editorial 
cartoon, “News Junkie,” that pokes fun at media stereotypes and 
shortcomings. While the media criticism programs on cable news, “Fox News 
Watch” and CNN’s “Reliable Sources,” emphasize debates among guests, “The 
IFC Media Project” prefers taped segments and one-on-one interviews. The 
third episode applies neuroscience to so-called shout shows to see why 
pundit-driven talk is so entertaining to viewers.

Mr. Yago said the program seeks to praise great journalism just as it 
criticizes questionable media practices. “Mostly,” he said, “it’s trying to 
get into the process — to ask why stories become news and how stories get 
to the top of the queue.”


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to