Apple vs. Palm: the in-depth analysis

by Nilay Patel
January 28 2009
Engadget

Apple and Palm kicked a lot of dirt at each other last week -- acting
Apple CEO Tim Cook flatly told analysts that "We will not stand for
people ripping off our IP" when asked specifically about competition
like the Palm Pre, and Palm responded with a similarly-explicit "We
have the tools necessary to defend ourselves." At issue, of course,
is that the Pre employs a multitouch screen and gestures almost
exactly like those made famous on the iPhone -- and if you'll recall,
Steve Jobs introduced multitouch on the iPhone with a slide reading
"Patented!" To top it all off, the past few days have seen a number
of media outlets proclaim that Apple's been awarded a "multitouch
patent" without so much as a shred of analysis, instead hyping up a
supposed future conflict. That's just not how we play it, so we
enlisted Mathew Gavronski, a patent attorney in the Chicago office of
Michael Best & Friedrich, to help us clear up some of the confusion
and misinformation that's out there -- read on for more.


Just a couple notes before we begin: first, we're not going to get
into whether or not Apple or Palm should have been granted particular
patents or if the patent system is working as it should -- that's a
philosophical argument way outside the scope of any potential lawsuit
that might arise. Suffice it to say that although we're aware the
patent system has flaws, there's no debating that people and
companies should be compensated for their work, and we're not going
to begrudge Apple or Palm for trying to do everything they can within
rules of the current system to protect and profit from the hundreds
of millions of dollars each has spent on R&D. You can bet the public
policy implications of the patent system don't keep Ed Colligan or
Steve Jobs up at night; we're going to assume both sides will be
using every trick and decades-old patent it can find to win a
potential lawsuit.

Second, while we can sit here and play with an iPhone to figure out
what exactly Apple's trying to patent, we really don't have much to
go on with the Pre apart from some brief hands-on time with units
running alpha-level code at CES, so we can't really make definitive
calls one way or another. A lot can change between now and whenever
the Pre is launched, so while we're going to do our best to identify
the elements of the Pre and the iPhone that could potentially
infringe Apple or Palm patents, treat the Pre stuff with an extra
dose of salt.

So now that we've got the caveats out of the way, let's get started
breaking down the areas where Apple and Palm can really do some
courtroom damage, shall we?

...

http://www.engadget.com/2009/01/28/apple-vs-palm-the-in-depth-analysis/

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to