MARCH 17, 2009

Intel Threatens Fight Over AMD Spinoff

By DON CLARK
Wall Street Journal

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123721536373742063.html


Intel Corp. said Advanced Micro Devices Inc.'s deal to spin off its 
manufacturing operations breaches a patent-licensing pact between the 
companies, and threatened to cut off AMD's rights to use the patents in 
60 days.

AMD recently spun off the operations -- which include factories in 
Dresden, Germany, that continue to manufacture chips for AMD -- to a new 
company that is largely funded by investors from Abu Dhabi.

AMD retains an ownership interest in the venture, which is called 
Globalfoundries.

The dispute hinges on whether the venture can be considered an AMD 
subsidiary, as defined by a 2001 agreement between the rivals to share 
intellectual property.

Intel argues Globalfoundries isn't an AMD subsidiary, and therefore the 
venture doesn't have rights to use its patents to make chips.

Harry Wolin, AMD's general counsel, said the Globalfoundries deal meets 
the requirements of a subsidiary as laid out in the agreement with 
Intel: The parent company must contribute at least 50% of any spinoff's 
assets, retain at least 50% voting control and at least 30% interest in 
any profits or losses.

Intel's "legal arguments are incredibly weak, at best," Mr. Wolin said.

Bruce Sewell, Intel's general counsel, argued that AMD violates all 
three parts of the definition.

For example, while AMD counts the assets it is contributing to the 
venture, he said, it fails to consider AMD debts that Globalfoundries is 
assuming that reduces AMD's net contribution to the venture.

Intel also contends that the deal violates a confidential portion of the 
agreement that Mr. Sewell said prohibits AMD from setting up any 
corporate structure that has the goal of extending patent rights to a 
third party.

"It's clear to us that AMD has gone down this path precisely in order to 
get around the requirement," Mr. Sewell said.

Mr. Sewell said Intel remains open to negotiating a patent-license 
arrangement with Globalfoundries.

Without one, he said, Intel faces the possibility that the new venture 
could use its patents in making chips for other companies besides AMD.

Intel has raised legal questions about the spinoff plan since AMD 
announced it in October.

Lawyers from the two companies met last week to discuss the issues, Mr. 
Sewell said, and Intel followed up with a letter to AMD that accuses AMD 
of committing a material breach of the license.

Under terms of the license agreement, the companies are expected to 
begin a mediation process.

But Intel said it is invoking its right to terminate AMD's license to 
Intel patents in 60 days unless AMD corrects the alleged breach of the 
agreement. AMD, in turn, said Intel's actions to terminate its rights 
also entitle AMD to terminate Intel's rights to AMD's patents.

The dispute is the latest in a series of legal battles between the 
companies, including a private antitrust suit that AMD filed against 
Intel in June 2005.

A spokesman for Globalfoundries characterized Intel's latest action as a 
"diversionary tactic" to distract from global antitrust scrutiny that 
Intel faces.

"We remain on track to manufacture products for AMD and other future 
customers," he said.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to