March 26, 2009

Doctors Raise Doubts on Digital Health Data
By STEVE LOHR
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/26/business/26health.html?ref=technology&pagewanted=print


Now that the federal government plans to spend $19 billion to spur the 
use of computerized patient records, the challenge of adopting the 
technology widely and wisely is becoming increasingly apparent.

Two articles, to be published on Thursday in the New England Journal of 
Medicine, point to the formidable obstacles to achieving the policy goal 
of not only installing electronic health records, but also using them to 
improve care and curb costs.

One article reports that only 9 percent of the nation’s hospitals have 
electronic health records, based on a survey of nearly 3,000 hospitals. 
The study, financed by the federal government and the Robert Wood 
Johnson Foundation, is the most definitive measure to date of the use of 
computerized patient records by hospitals. The government-backed study 
found a far lower level of use than some earlier, less rigorous surveys.

The study, the authors said, measured only the adoption of digital 
patient records. The survey did not ask whether the electronic records 
were used to advance the health policy goals of the federal plan, like 
tracking the quality of care and communicating effectively with outside 
specialists and clinics to coordinate a patient’s care.

“We have a long way to go,” said Dr. Ashish K. Jha, an assistant 
professor at the Harvard School of Public Health who was the article’s 
lead author. “And we did not measure effective use. Even if a hospital 
does have electronic health records, it does not mean it is sharing 
information with other hospitals and doctors down the road.”

In a second article in the journal, two experts in health information 
technology at Children’s Hospital Boston assert that spending billions 
of dollars of federal funds to stimulate the adoption of existing forms 
of health record software would be a costly policy mistake.

In the article, identified as a “perspective,” Dr. Kenneth D. Mandl and 
Dr. Isaac S. Kohane portray the current health record suppliers as 
offering pre-Internet era software — costly and wedded to proprietary 
technology standards that make it difficult for customers to switch 
vendors and for outside programmers to make upgrades and improvements.

Instead of stimulating use of such software, they say, the government 
should be a rule-setting referee to encourage the development of an open 
software platform on which innovators could write electronic health 
record applications. As analogies, they point to other such software 
platforms — whether the Web or Apple’s iPhone software, which the 
company has opened to outside developers.

In the Mandl-Kohane model, a software developer with a new idea for 
health record features like drug allergy alerts or care guidelines could 
write an application, and those could be added or substituted for a 
similar feature.

Such an approach, they say, would open the door to competition, 
flexibility and lower costs — and thus, better health care in the long 
run. “If the government’s money goes to cement the current technology in 
place,” Dr. Mandl said in an interview, “we will have a very hard time 
innovating in health care reform.”

To justify spending taxpayers’ money, the government program must expand 
digital records beyond routine tasks like billing to focus on “how the 
technology will be used to improve clinical performance,” said Herbert 
S. Lin, a senior scientist the National Academy of Sciences, an advisory 
group to the government.

The Obama administration’s health technology plan, which is part of the 
economic recovery package, includes incentive payments for adopting 
electronic health records — more than $40,000 per physician and up to 
several million dollars for hospitals. The payments are spread over a 
few years and are based on “meaningful use” of “certified” records, 
although Congress left defining those terms to the Department of Health 
and Human Services.

The incentive payments, industry experts say, are enough to greatly 
accelerate the adoption of electronic health records. In the new survey 
of hospitals, the cost of digital record systems was cited as the single 
largest obstacle to adoption.

Dr. David Blumenthal, a professor at the Harvard Medical School, oversaw 
the hospital study. Last week he was named the national coordinator for 
health information technology in the Obama administration. In a 
conference call to discuss the study, Dr. Blumenthal declined to talk 
about his plans in detail.

But clearly, he sees electronic health records as a tool to reform 
health care, and the Obama administration intends to shift Medicare and 
Medicaid reimbursement toward paying for better health outcomes, which 
will be measured and monitored using technology.

“The goals are quality and efficiency, instead of just putting machinery 
in offices,” Dr. Blumenthal said. “If we encourage better performance, 
then physicians are going to find ways to improve performance. And 
health information technology is one crucial way to do that.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to