Digital TV Transition: A House Divided
Democrat, GOP Views Underline Party Differences On Changeover From Analog

By John Eggerton
Multichannel News

March 26, 2009

http://www.multichannel.com/article/print/190732-Digital_TV_Transition_A_House_Divided.php


Wednesday's DTV transition oversight hearing in the House Communications, 
Technology and Internet Subcommittee showed once again the stark political 
divide in the view of that transition.

What was called a "phased" transition by Democrats was branded 
"scattershot" by the other side.

Republicans said the delay to June 12 was unnecessary and a waste of $650 
million, while Democrats said it was necessary to making sure millions of 
viewers did not lost their signals and to clear up confusion cause by the 
previous administration's handling of the program.

As reported Wednesday, subcommittee chairman Rick Boucher (D-Va.), who 
backed moving the date, praised the industry and the FCC for its education 
efforts, though he did say that challenges lie ahead.

But Boucher expressed concerns over possible reception issues and 
aviailability of converter boxes, saying that based on current redemption 
rates, there would be a need for over 5 million boxes at least, while the 
consumer electronics industry was anticipating only 4.2 million would be 
needed.

Anna Gomez, acting head of the National Telecommunications & Information 
Administration, said she shared Boucher's concern, but that up until now 
inventory levels had been "good," and that her agency was continuing to 
monitor the situation and coordinating with the industry on where the boxes 
were needed.

Ranking member Cliff Stearns (R-Fla/) said that despite arm-twisting by 
government, the hundreds of stations that went ahead and made the 
transition on Feb. 17 experienced few problems. He also made the argument, 
echoed by other Republicans, including John Shimkus of Illinois, that some 
percentage of households were going to be unready no matter what the 
government did or when it made the switch.

Democrat Anthony Weiner of New York said that might be true, but noted that 
the answer should not be "tough tacos, you are going to lose your service," 
and blamed the Bush administration's handling of the transition, saying 
Democrats were mopping up after the DTV transition, just as they were other 
messes left behind.

Acting FCC chairman Michael Copps agreed that the FCC had not been 
prepared. He said the agency was trying to play catch-up, but could not 
guarantee there would not be problems, particularly with signal pattern 
changes between analog and digital. He said the FCC was working on 
implementing programs to help broadcasters fill in coverage gaps, but that 
took time and money, both of which were in short supply.

The FCC will at least have some more money to bolster call centers and for 
education and outreach to help inform viewers of potential signal losses no 
matter what steps they take to prepare.

Gomez said the FCC had asked for $65 million in funding from the $90 
million in administration and other funding Congress gave it as part of the 
$650 million DTV funding in the economic stimulus package.

Copps said some of that would go for a new RFP to improve its call center 
effort.

One who didn't have many encouraging words was John Dingell (D-Mich.), 
former chairman of the Commerce Committee, who suggested the FCC's 
education program was "disastrously mismanaged and largely ineffectual." He 
slammed NITA, albeit not Gomez, who is new to the post, for having told 
Congress last session that it had enough money to handle a spike in coupon 
requests--NTIA ran out of funding at the end of December when that spike 
occurred.

Dingell said he did not have confidence that the transition would go well 
without being watched very closely by Congress.

Dingell pressed both Gomez and Copps on education efforts and funding, and 
indicated he was not entirely happy with the answers. He was looking for 
assurances that both had enough funding to make sure he did not receive 
angry calls from disaffected viewers. "You have not comforted me," Dingell 
told Gomez after a series of tough questions.

The DTV delay act allows households to reapply for coupons that have 
expired. Republicans on the committee urged it to put analog-only homes at 
the head of the line, and not the cable and satellite homes applying for 
converter boxes for second or third sets.

Gomez said that NTIA was ready to prioritize requests to put analog-only 
homes first if another waiting list situation loomed, but until then was 
not doing so. Boucher agreed that was the right way to approach it.

Stearns did not, saying that if NTIA confined itself to analog-only homes, 
rather than homes that will be able to get TV via cable and satellite, the 
government could get half a billion dollars back. More than one Republican 
suggested that while they might not seem like a lot of money in Washington 
these days, it was to them.


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to