AIG and US Airways Seek to Cover Up Flight 1549 Recovery Photos http://theonlinephotographer.typepad.com/the_online_photographer/2009/03/aig-and-us-airways-seek-to-cover-up-flight-1549-recovery-photos.html
Stephen Mallon might be sitting on some of the most newsworthy pictures never seen. Stephen, a New York City industrial photographer, was hired by Weeks Marine, the maritime crane company involved in the recovery of US Airways Flight 1549 from the Hudson River, to document the recovery process. Those who have seen the pictures say he did a wonderful job. He was given unlimited access on the water, to the plane's interior, virtually anywhere he wanted to go. He had the full cooperation and blessing of his immediate client, Weeks Marine; of the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB); and of USAirways. He never signed a Work for Hire agreement, and his client had no problem with him publishing the work non-commerically—like, on his website, where he posted them. The best shots from the more than 5,000 captures he made amounted to "an incredible, beautiful document of the recovery," according to Pulitzer-Prizewinning photo editor Stella Kramer, who saw them. (The two pictures posted here were published elsewhere while they were still available from Stephen.) That's when the funny business started. Stephen put the pictures up on his website, where they were viewable for about a week. Then he got a correction from the NTSB: no, he could not "go live" with the pictures. So he took them down. Two weeks later, the NTSB released them, so all but a couple went up again. Then a couple more had to come down. And so on. Then he got a letter from J. Supor & Son, a land-based crane company, saying they were asserting their rights to be considered his client, based on their ownership of Weeks Marine, which, you recall, had hired Stephen in the first place. Then he got a letter from a law firm, not sent directly but passed to him by insurance giant AIG—yup, that AIG—asserting that Stephen has no rights to his pictures, and that the pictures absolutely can't be released to anyone, ever—not even news outlets for news purposes. AIG (through its lawyers) apparently seeks total suppression of the work, indefinitely. Based on...what rights, explicitly? Stephen isn't sure. Like any photographer, Stephen owns the rights to his pictures, except those rights he signed away in his contract with Weeks. AIG is US Airways' insurer. Ultimately, they'll be paying for the salvage operation and for a new airplane. But they weren't Stephen's client. The ASMP is urging him to proceed with caution, for which I emphatically don't blame him—a sole proprietor photographer has a hard enough row to hoe as it is, without a giant multinational corporation trying with all their might to make his life miserable. And based on...what motivation, exactly? Why is AIG seeking to suppress the photos of the recovery? It's not like they can cover up the fact that the plane ended up in the Hudson River. No one's disputing that. It's been reported all over the world. And why would US Airways participate in a cover-up? If ever there was one, the Hudson River crash was an example of an airline doing everything right! Not a single life was lost; the pilot and crew performed bravely and brilliantly, and are national heroes as a result—they got a standing O from the U.S. Congress, for Pete's sake. It's hard to imagine a better outcome for a dire emergency situation that results in a crash landing. If you had to be in a plane crash, wouldn't you want it to be a US Airways flight with the intrepid Sully Sullenberger at the controls? So why the cover up? Stephen can't figure it out. And he has the photos...not just the ones that were posted on his site, but, of course, all his shooting from the scene. And he can't see anything incriminating about the pictures. You and I, of course, can't see for ourselves. The national news media has yet to pick this story up. I just called up Stephen at his New York studio. He's got the scoop. NBC, CBS, ABC, PBS, NYT, etc.—your move. So, can you help? Stephen thinks maybe you can. He's asking members of the public to write or call AIG and US Airways to help put public pressure on them to allow him to release his photos to public view. While we're at it, let's ask them what they think they're hiding! I for one am curious to know that. (Also, if you're a lawyer, what's your take on this? Obviously Stephen can't use his clients' pictures for commercial purposes, but what about their newsworthiness? Does Free Speech trump AIG's rights to suppress the work? I don't know, I'm just asking.) -- Gregory S. Williams gregwilliams(at)knology.net k4hsm(at)knology.net *********************************** * POST TO [email protected] * *********************************** Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
