Judge Temporarily Bars Prosecutor from Charging Teens for Child Porn Pics

By Kim Zetter
Wired News

March 30, 2009 | 7:02:51 PM

http://blog.wired.com/27bstroke6/2009/03/judge-bars-da-f.html


A federal judge in Pennsylvania has granted a temporary restraining order 
to prevent a district attorney from charging three teenage girls with the 
production of child pornography for allowing someone to take photos of them 
in states of undress.

In his ruling the judge seemed to agree with the plaintiffs that the images 
in question do not qualify as child pornography.

At issue in the case are photos seized from student cellphones last year by 
officials of the Tunkhannock School District in Wyoming County, 
Pennsylvania. The practice of taking nude or semi-nude self-portraits and 
distributing them via a cellphone or the internet has come to be called 
"sexting" and has resulted in teens being arrested in a number of states 
under child porn production, distribution and possession charges.

The Tunkhannock case involves two photos depicting the three girls. One 
photo of Marissa Miller and Grace Kelly shows them two years ago at age 13 
lying side by side while one talks on the phone and the other makes a peace 
sign with her fingers, according to the ACLU complaint. The two are 
photographed from the waist up and are wearing white opaque bras. A second 
photo shows a girl referred to in the court document as "Jane Doe" 
photographed outside a shower with a towel wrapped around her waist. Her 
breasts are bared.

Wyoming County District Attorney George Skumanick, Jr., had threatened to 
charge the girls with being accomplices to the production of child 
pornography unless they agreed to six-month probation, drug-testing and 
participation in a five-week educational program to discuss why what they 
did was wrong.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania sued the district 
attorney on behalf of the teens and their parents on grounds that the DA 
was violating their civil rights. The plaintiffs said the images didn't 
qualify as child pornography under Pennsylvania's laws and therefore the 
prosecutor was prohibiting their free expression to take photos of 
themselves. They also claimed the attempt to force the parents to put the 
girls in an educational program violated their Fourteenth Amendment rights.

U.S. District Court Judge James M. Munley granted the temporary restraining 
order on grounds that the plaintiffs stand a reasonable chance of winning 
their suit against the prosecutor. The judge didn't comment on the merits 
of their claims against the prosecutor other than to say that the 
"plaintiffs make a reasonable argument that the images presented to the 
court do not appear to qualify in any way as depictions of prohibited 
sexual acts."

"We are grateful the judge recognized that prosecuting our clients for 
non-sexually explicit photographs raises serious constitutional questions," 
said Witold Walczack, legal director for the ACLU of Pennsylvania, in a 
statement. "This country needs to have a discussion about whether 
prosecuting minors as child pornographers for merely being impulsive and 
naive is the appropriate way to address the serious consequences that can 
result from sexting."

Walczack told Threat Level that during the hearing the judge had looked at 
the two photos in question and asked the lawyers representing the 
defendant, "I just want to be clear that these are the two photos that are 
illegal?"

"He had sort of this incredulous tone in his voice," Walczack said. "I 
think there is an important message for prosecutors that they need to be 
careful about threatening child porn charges when you don't really have 
child porn."

Skumanick was not available for comment. The district attorney is up for 
re-election in May.

A hearing to address the plaintiffs' request for a preliminary injunction 
will be held June 2.


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to