May 9, 2009 3:14 PM PDT

EC wants software makers held liable for code

By Tom Espiner
News.com

http://news.cnet.com/8301-1001_3-10237212-92.html?tag=mncol


Software companies could be held responsible for the security and 
efficacy of their products, if a new European Commission consumer 
protection proposal becomes law.

Commissioners Viviane Reding and Meglena Kuneva have proposed that EU 
consumer protections for physical products be extended to software. The 
suggested change in the law is part of an EU action agenda put forward 
by the commissioners after identifying gaps in EU consumer protection rules.

A priority area for possible EU action is "extending the principles of 
consumer protection rules to cover licensing agreements of products like 
software downloaded for virus protection, games, or other licensed 
content," according to the commissioners' agenda. "Licensing should 
guarantee consumers the same basic rights as when they purchase a good: 
the right to get a product that works with fair commercial conditions."

EU consumer commissioner Kuneva said that more accountability for 
software makers, and for companies providing digital services, would 
lead to greater consumer choice.

"If we want consumers to shop around and exploit the potential of 
digital communications, then we need to give them confidence that their 
rights are guaranteed," Kuneva said. "That means putting in place and 
enforcing clear consumer rights that meet the high standards already 
existing in the main street. (The) Internet has everything to offer 
consumers, but we need to build trust so that people can shop around 
with peace of mind."

The Business Software Alliance (BSA), which represents the interests of 
software makers including Apple, IBM, and Microsoft, criticized the 
proposals.

"Digital content is not a tangible good and should not be subject to the 
same liability rules as toasters," Francisco Mingorance, BSA director of 
public policy told ZDNet UK on Thursday. "Unlike tangible goods, 
creators of digital content cannot predict with a high degree of 
certainty both the product's anticipated uses and its potential 
performance."

Mingorance said the performance of a piece of software depends on the 
environment it operates in, how the code is updated, whether it is 
possible to adapt and modify the software, and whether the code is attacked.

According to Mingorance, the proposed regulatory extension would cover 
all software, including beta products, and would cover both proprietary 
and open-source software.

Right now, under the current EU Sales and Guarantees Directive, physical 
products are expected to carry a guarantee of two years. Extending those 
terms to software would have the effect of limiting customer choice, as 
contract terms would have to be extended to a minimum of two years, 
Mingorance added.

"Extending the scope would force the businesses to maintain update 
services for such contracts beyond the contractual term and ultimately 
limit the choice of offers," the BSA director said. "It is like renting 
your house for a summer month and being then obliged to extend the rent 
for another 23 months."

In addition, Mingorance said that extending consumer regulation to 
software could lead to less interoperability between software products, 
as manufacturers might decide to limit how far third-party developers 
could access their code.

Software companies have long argued against accepting responsibility for 
the security and efficiency of their code. Linux kernel developer Alan 
Cox in 2007 told a House of Lords Committee that neither proprietary nor 
open-source developers should be held accountable for their code.

---------------
Tom Espiner of ZDNet UK reported from London.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to